| Points | Name | Value | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 87 | James E Pepper Gold Label Bourbon | GOOD | $70 |
| 84 | Old Pepper 100% Rye Single Barrel (Norfolk Wine) | OK | $60 |
| 83 | Old Pepper Single Malt Single Barrel – Distillery exclusive | OK | $100 |
| 89 | Old Pepper Rye Single Barrel (First FIll Spirits) | BEST | $55 |
| 74 | Old Pepper Finest Kentucky Oak Straight Rye – Distillery Exclusive | POOR | $80 |
| 86 | Old Pepper Single Barrel Rye – Batch K06 | OK | $80 |