| 89 |
Bardstown – Fercullen Blended Whiskey Collaborative Series |
POOR |
$200 |
| 85 |
Shady Knoll Single Barrel Rye Whiskey |
POOR |
$86 |
| 83 |
Shady Knoll Rye Whiskey |
OK |
$50 |
| 90 |
Little Rest Oloroso Sherry Hogshead – Distillery Exclusive |
OK |
$185 |
| 91 |
Little Rest Double Matured Cask Strength American Single Malt Whisky |
BEST |
$135 |
| 87 |
Little Rest American Single Malt Whisky – Port Cask |
GOOD |
$125 |
| 88 |
Little Rest Founders Edition American Single Malt Whisky |
OK |
$155 |
| 85 |
Lost Lantern Shadow Blended American Malt Whiskey (Edition 2023 SHD-1) |
OK |
$93 |
| 86 |
Lost Lantern Flame American Blended Malt Whiskey |
OK |
$93 |
| 87 |
St George Mountain Meadow Single Malt 4 Yr (Lost Lantern Edition 2023 STG-1) |
OK |
$140 |
| 85 |
Cedar Ridge Iowa Straight Wheat Whiskey 6 Yr (Lost Lantern 2024 Single Cask # 6) |
GOOD |
$86 |
| 91 |
Tom’s Foolery Ohio Straight Rye 9 Yr (Lost Lantern 2024 Single Cask # 4) |
OK |
$116 |
| 86 |
FEW Spirits Illinois 5 Yr Straight Bourbon Whiskey (Lost Lantern 2024 Single Cask # 3) |
POOR |
$86 |
| 89 |
Starlight Single Cask Straight Bourbon 6 Yr (Lost Lantern 2024 Single Cask # 1) |
OK |
$86 |
| 89 |
Lost Lantern Far Flung Rye |
OK |
$100 |
| 91 |
Westland 9 Yr American Single Malt (Raising Glasses – VOODOO Cask # 6253) |
BEST |
$90 |
| 86 |
Westland 8 Yr American Single Malt (Raising Glasses – BLOOM Cask # 2478) |
GOOD |
$90 |
| 88 |
Westland 8 Yr American Single Malt (Raising Glasses – STORIES Cask #6540) |
BEST |
$90 |
| 88 |
Barrell Dovetail Whiskey |
BEST |
$90 |
| 91 |
E.J. Curley Kentucky Bourbon Single Barrel |
BEST |
$76 |
| 88 |
Boone County 6-Yr Single Barrel Bourbon (First Fill Spirits) |
GOOD |
$70 |
| 92 |
Green River Single Barrel Bourbon (First Fill Spirits) |
BEST |
$70 |
| 86 |
New Riff Sour Mash Single Malt Cask Strength Whiskey |
GOOD |
$95 |
| 80 |
Spirits of French Lick Hindostan Falls Botted-In-Bond Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$60 |
| 90 |
NULU Double Oaked Bourbon, Barrel B1003 (Westport) |
GOOD |
$87 |
| 89 |
O.K.I. Reserve Blended Bourbon Whiskey Batch 1 |
GOOD |
$80 |
| 87 |
Russell’s Reserve Private Barrel Selection (Westport) |
GOOD |
$80 |
| 87 |
Boone County Founder’s Reserve Bourbon Finished in Amburana Casks |
GOOD |
$70 |
| 85 |
Ry3 Rye Whiskey Finished in Madeira Casks (Party Source – Batch PR#006) |
POOR |
$88 |
| 76 |
Copper & Kings Bourbon Finished in Apple Brandy Barrels |
POOR |
$65 |
| 86 |
Del Bac Dorado American Single Malt Whiskey |
BEST |
$65 |
| 89 |
Cedar Ridge Barrel Proof Small Batch Bourbon (Batch 0003) |
BEST |
$50 |
| 87 |
Castle & Key Restoration Rye Single Barrel (Gordon’s Store Pick) |
BEST |
$65 |
| 88 |
Old Line American Single Malt (Saratoga Whiskey Club) |
BEST |
$60 |
| 89 |
Little Rest American Single Malt Whisky – Pinot Noir Cask Batch 001 |
GOOD |
$110 |
| 86 |
Little Rest American Single Malt Whisky – Bourbon Cask Batch 001 |
OK |
$110 |
| 89 |
Little Rest American Single Malt Whisky – Batch 002 (Classic) |
BEST |
$100 |
| 86 |
Smoke Wagon Straight Rye Whiskey Private Barrel M15 |
POOR |
$90 |
| 93 |
George T. Stagg Kentucky Straight Bourbon 2022 |
OK |
$150 |
| 86 |
Obtanium Light Whiskey (First Fill Spirits) |
GOOD |
$80 |
| 92 |
Calumet Farm 15 Yr Single Rack Black “Whirlaway” Kentucky Straight Bourbon (Rack # P2613.09) |
GOOD |
$130 |
| 89 |
Little Rest American Single Malt Whisky – First Edition |
POOR |
$175 |
| 89 |
Bardstown Bourbon Chateau de Laubade II |
POOR |
$160 |
| 91 |
Old Elk Infinity Blend |
GOOD |
$150 |
| 91 |
Blanton’s Straight From the Barrel Bourbon (Dumped 10-4-17, Barrel 1870) |
POOR |
$300 |
| 89 |
Maker’s Mark Wood Finishing Series 2023 BEP |
BEST |
$65 |
| 87 |
Maker’s Mark Wood Finishing Series 2022 BRT-02 |
BEST |
$65 |
| 85 |
Maker’s Mark Wood Finishing Series 2022 BRT-01 |
GOOD |
$60 |
| 90 |
Maker’s Mark Wood Finishing Series 2021 FAE-02 |
BEST |
$65 |
| 89 |
Maker’s Mark Wood Finishing Series 2021 FAE-01 |
BEST |
$65 |
| 85 |
Maker’s Mark Wood Finishing Series 2020 SE4 x PR5 |
GOOD |
$60 |
| 88 |
Maker’s Mark Wood Finishing Series 2019 RC6 |
GOOD |
$68 |
| 84 |
Kinsey 4 Yr American Whiskey |
GOOD |
$40 |
| 91 |
Milwaukee’s Club 29th Anniversary American Style Whiskey, Double Matured Single Barrel |
POOR |
$2000 |
| 90 |
NULU Single Barrel 8 Yr Bourbon (Barrel # 1) |
OK |
$110 |
| 82 |
King’s Family Distillery American Whiskey Finished in Islay Casks |
POOR |
$70 |
| 90 |
King’s Family Distillery Ryeconic Rye Whiskey |
BEST |
$60 |
| 88 |
King’s Family Distillery 6 Yr Straight Rye |
GOOD |
$69 |
| 90 |
King’s Family Distillery Tennessee Standard Bourbon |
BEST |
$70 |
| 89 |
King’s Family Distillery Wheated 5 Year Bourbon |
GOOD |
$70 |
| 88 |
Westland American Single Malt, Single Cask (Cask # 2781) |
GOOD |
$125 |
| 95 |
Milwaukee’s Club 30th Anniversary American Style Whiskey, Cask # 1568 |
POOR |
$400 |
| 79 |
Barrell American Vatted Malt Whiskey |
POOR |
$80 |
| 90 |
Barrell Craft Spirits Gray Label Bourbon, 5th Release |
POOR |
$250 |
| 88 |
Barrell Vantage Bourbon |
GOOD |
$80 |
| 87 |
Barrell Bourbon New Year 2023 |
OK |
$85 |
| 88 |
Boone County 5 Yr Single Barrel Pot Still Bourbon: Barrel BCP1 |
GOOD |
$70 |
| 82 |
Smoke Wagon Malted Straight Rye Whiskey |
POOR |
$80 |
| 86 |
Blanton’s Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon (Bayway) |
OK |
$75 |
| 84 |
Elijah Craig Barrel Proof – Private Barrel # 6634306 (Bayway World of Liquor) |
OK |
$65 |
| 85 |
Wellwood Gardens Wheated Bourbon |
GOOD |
$50 |
| 84 |
Down Home Straight Rye Finished in Toasted White Oak Barrels |
POOR |
$73 |
| 86 |
Old Scout Single Barrel Bourbon – Barrel 24478 (Party Source) |
OK |
$70 |
| 89 |
New Riff Single Barrel Rye – (Westport Whiskey & Wine) |
GOOD |
$75 |
| 87 |
Fortuna Kentucky Straight Bourbon, Batch 1F |
OK |
$85 |
| 85 |
Peerless Single Barrel Rye (Westport Whiskey & Wine, Barrel # R170103106) |
POOR |
$85 |
| 82 |
Balcones Texas Single Malt Whiskey Single Barrel (Total Wine) |
OK |
$65 |
| 86 |
Nelson Bros. Reserve Bourbon Whiskey |
GOOD |
$60 |
| 86 |
High Plains Rye |
GOOD |
$60 |
| 81 |
Barrell Craft Spirits Single Barrel Bourbon (Barrel 23A5 – Westport Whiskey & Wine) |
POOR |
$95 |
| 89 |
Stranahan’s Colorado Whiskey, Barrel 12-0819 (Total Wine) |
BEST |
$75 |
| 88 |
Starlight Carl T Huber’s Single Barrel Bourbon Finished in Cognac Barrels |
GOOD |
$75 |
| 94 |
Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon, Batch C922 |
BEST |
$105 |
| 90 |
Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon, Batch B522 |
BEST |
$69 |
| 93 |
Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon, Batch A122 |
GOOD |
$110 |
| 90 |
Larceny Kentucky Straight Bourbon Barrel Proof, Batch C920 |
POOR |
$250 |
| 85 |
Larceny Kentucky Straight Bourbon Barrel Proof, Batch B520 |
GOOD |
$55 |
| 90 |
Larceny Kentucky Straight Bourbon Barrel Proof, Batch A120 |
POOR |
$160 |
| 89 |
New Riff Single Barrel Bourbon, Barrel 11590 |
BEST |
$55 |
| 91 |
NULU Toasted Bourbon, Barrel B79T |
GOOD |
$85 |
| 88 |
NULU Double Oaked Bourbon, Barrel C151 |
POOR |
$110 |
| 90 |
NULU Single-Barrel Bourbon, Barrel W6 |
GOOD |
$85 |
| 86 |
NULU Double Oaked Bourbon, Barrel W8 |
POOR |
$100 |
| 92 |
NULU Toasted Bourbon, Barrel W9T |
BEST |
$85 |
| 85 |
NULU Bourbon Finished in French Oak Barrels – Experimental Finish Series, Barrel B732 |
POOR |
$100 |
| 91 |
NULU Cask Strength Uncut Straight Bourbon, Batch 1 |
GOOD |
$85 |
| 87 |
NULU Toasted Bourbon Barrel B509T |
OK |
$85 |
| 74 |
291 Colorado Bourbon Whiskey Barrel Proof Single Barrel – Aspen Wood Stave Finish |
POOR |
$110 |
| 90 |
Blackwood Toasted Bourbon, Batch 1 |
POOR |
$150 |
| 87 |
Copper & Kings Apple Brandy Finished Bourbon: 7 Yr Hand Fill |
BEST |
$65 |
| 93 |
NULU Double Oaked Bourbon (Party Source) |
BEST |
$100 |
| 85 |
Heaven’s Door Decades 10 Yr Bourbon |
POOR |
$120 |
| 91 |
Blood Oath Pact No. 8 |
POOR |
$150 |
| 91 |
Lucky Seven The Proprietor 14 Yr Single Barrel Straight Bourbon, Barrel # 97 (First Fill Spirits) |
POOR |
$170 |
| 84 |
Helderberg Winter Wheat Whiskey Batch 001 |
GOOD |
$50 |
| 90 |
Sherbrook Barrel Proof Unfiltered Straight Rye Whiskey 14 Yr |
POOR |
$200 |
| 88 |
Blue Note Juke Joint Uncut Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
BEST |
$40 |
| 90 |
King’s Family Distillery Bourbon Whiskey Finished in a Honey Barrel |
BEST |
$65 |
| 89 |
Doc Swinson’s Alter Ego Solera Method Straight Rye Whiskey |
BEST |
$50 |
| 86 |
Del Bac The 9th Floor American Single Malt Private Barrel |
BEST |
$71 |
| 86 |
Copperworks 3 Yr Single Malt (SMWS 143.1 Sea Buckthorn Tea Time) |
GOOD |
$95 |
| 90 |
Wattie Boone & Sons 9 Year Small Batch American Whiskey |
GOOD |
$100 |
| 90 |
Peerless Single Barrel Bourbon “Lemon and Licorice” – Distillery Exclusive |
GOOD |
$100 |
| 87 |
Black Button Single Barrel # 3092 Straight Bourbon (First Fill Spirits) |
GOOD |
$68 |
| 89 |
Whiskey War Barrel Proof |
BEST |
$50 |
| 90 |
J Mattingly 1845 Single Barrel Light Whiskey (Party Source) |
BEST |
$120 |
| 89 |
Balcones Single Barrel Single Malt (Total Wine Store Pick) |
BEST |
$80 |
| 87 |
Balcones 4 Yr Single Malt (SMWS 140.4 Throws you curve balls) |
BEST |
$95 |
| 83 |
Old Pepper Single Malt Single Barrel – Distillery exclusive |
OK |
$100 |
| 92 |
Proof and Wood ‘Seasons 2021’ American Blended Whiskey |
OK |
$197 |
| 88 |
Proof and Wood Vertigo 2021 |
OK |
$140 |
| 88 |
Smooth Ambler Contradiction Rye Whiskey |
BEST |
$41 |
| 83 |
Wood Hat Bourbon Rubenesque |
OK |
$58 |
| 89 |
Old Pepper Rye Single Barrel (First FIll Spirits) |
BEST |
$55 |
| 89 |
Cardinal Spirits Barrel Proof Bourbon (First Fill Spirits) |
BEST |
$50 |
| 81 |
Cooperstown Select American Single Malt Sherry Cask Finished |
OK |
$75 |
| 91 |
Penelope Bourbon Toasted 4-Grain (First Fill Spirits) – Batch S2, Cask 490 |
BEST |
$73 |
| 85 |
Rough Rider “The Big Stick” Rye Whiskey Cask Strength, Batch 32 |
GOOD |
$60 |
| 89 |
Penelope 13 Yr American Light Whiskey |
GOOD |
$100 |
| 82 |
Laws San Luis Valley Straight Rye Cask |
POOR |
$86 |
| 84 |
Woodinville Cask Strength Straight Rye Whiskey |
POOR |
$70 |
| 90 |
New York Distilling Rye 4 Yr (SMWS RW3.2 Brooklyn Apple Pie) |
BEST |
$75 |
| 87 |
George Dickel Leopold Bros Collaboration Rye Blend |
POOR |
$110 |
| 89 |
New Riff Malted Rye 6 Yr |
GOOD |
$70 |
| 88 |
Sagamore Spirit 8 Yr Rye Reserve Series |
GOOD |
$80 |
| 86 |
Breckenridge Bourbon High Proof |
GOOD |
$53 |
| 85 |
Old Potrero Hotaling’s Rye Whiskey (Gordon’s Store Pick) |
POOR |
$90 |
| 87 |
Smooth Ambler Single Barrel Rye (Barrel # 16797) |
BEST |
$53 |
| 91 |
NULU Toasted Rye Barrel Proof Single Barrel Select (First Fill Spirits) |
GOOD |
$100 |
| 87 |
Leopold Bros Cask Select Straight Bourbon Whiskey (First Fill Spirits) |
BEST |
$58 |
| 89 |
Town Branch Kentucky Straight Bourbon (First Fill Spirits) |
BEST |
$45 |
| 86 |
Woodinville Bourbon finished in Port Casks (Distillery Exclusive) |
GOOD |
$50 |
| 93 |
1792 Full Proof Bourbon (Bayway Store Pick) |
BEST |
$65 |
| 74 |
Old Pepper Finest Kentucky Oak Straight Rye – Distillery Exclusive |
POOR |
$80 |
| 85 |
Cardinal Spirits Bourbon Barrel Proof (Party Source Store Pick) |
GOOD |
$52 |
| 85 |
Boone County Pot Still Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
GOOD |
$50 |
| 85 |
Castle & Key Restoration Rye Batch 3 |
GOOD |
$46 |
| 84 |
The Wiseman Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
OK |
$65 |
| 87 |
Jeptha Creed Hand-Filled Bourbon |
OK |
$100 |
| 83 |
Three Boys Hand-Filled Bourbon |
POOR |
$155 |
| 88 |
Barrell Bourbon New Year 2022 |
OK |
$85 |
| 86 |
Bardstown Bourbon Company Triple Blended Stave Finish |
POOR |
$200 |
| 86 |
Peerless Double Oak Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$135 |
| 85 |
Daviess County Limited Edition Double Barrel Bourbon |
GOOD |
$60 |
| 82 |
American Highway Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$100 |
| 86 |
Ragged Branch Double Oaked Signature Bourbon Virginia Straight Bourbon Whiskey (Barrel # 1905) |
GOOD |
$50 |
| 86 |
Stellum Bourbon Single Barrel – Lyra Barrel K3 (First Fill Spirits) |
GOOD |
$56 |
| 91 |
Boone County 6 Yr Single Barrel Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$150 |
| 90 |
Traverse City Barrel Proof Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
GOOD |
$85 |
| 87 |
NULU 5 Yr Single Barrel Straight Bourbon Whiskey – Barrel B310 |
BEST |
$56 |
| 85 |
Rock Town Bourbon (SMWS B3.9 Shooting Pool at a BBQ) |
POOR |
$120 |
| 87 |
Blue Note Bourbon – 17 Yr Barrel Proof |
POOR |
$400 |
| 89 |
Old Elk Single Barrel Wheated Bourbon (Exit 9) |
BEST |
$55 |
| 85 |
Pinhook Bourbon Heist – High Proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
GOOD |
$55 |
| 91 |
Heaven Hill 13 Yr Bottled in Bond Bourbon |
GOOD |
$100 |
| 90 |
Heaven Hill 27 Year Barrel Proof Small Batch Bourbon |
POOR |
$2000 |
| 86 |
Southern Tier Bottled-In-Bond Bourbon |
GOOD |
$57 |
| 87 |
Three Boys Farm Distillery Hand-Filled Rye |
POOR |
$157 |
| 87 |
Very Olde St Nick Cask Strength Rye Whiskey – Summer Rye |
POOR |
$169 |
| 88 |
Boone County Single Barrel Rye |
GOOD |
$69 |
| 86 |
Peerless Single Barrel Rye – “Apple Pie” (Justin’s House of Bourbon) |
POOR |
$95 |
| 86 |
Old Pepper Single Barrel Rye – Batch K06 |
OK |
$80 |
| 85 |
NULU Rye Single Barrel Toasted Barrel Finish (Total Wine) |
OK |
$72 |
| 88 |
Nashville Barrel Company Single Barrel (Total Wine) |
POOR |
$115 |
| 85 |
The Senator Barrel Proof Rye |
OK |
$80 |
| 79 |
Balcones True Blue Corn Whiskey – Cask Strength – Single Barrel (SF Wine Trading Co) |
POOR |
$60 |
| 87 |
Old Line American Single Malt Whiskey – Cask Strength |
BEST |
$55 |
| 86 |
Starlight Carl T Huber’s Single Barrel Bourbon 4 Yr (Total Wine) |
GOOD |
$50 |
| 85 |
George A. Dickel 15-Yr Single Barrel Bourbon |
GOOD |
$60 |
| 86 |
Rock Town Arkansas Bourbon 5 Yr (SMWS B3.8 Breakfast of Champions) |
OK |
$80 |
| 81 |
Westland Distillery & Lucky Envelope Brewing Cask Exchange American Single Malt Whiskey |
POOR |
$123 |
| 86 |
Woodinville Rye Cask Strength |
OK |
$70 |
| 88 |
Backbone Single Barrel Straight Bourbon Whiskey – Rum Finish (Prav Saraff) |
GOOD |
$70 |
| 88 |
Angel’s Envy Port Finished Bourbon – Single Barrel Private Selection (Party Source – Barrel 4150) |
OK |
$104 |
| 83 |
Old Scout Straight Bourbon Whiskey 5 Yr Single Barrel Select (Bourbon Outfitter) |
OK |
$55 |
| 87 |
Old Scout Straight Bourbon Whiskey 5 Yr Single Barrel Select (Potomac Wines & Spirits) |
BEST |
$50 |
| 81 |
Starlight Carl T. Huber’s Double Oaked Bourbon – Barrel DB003 (Prav Saraff) |
POOR |
$100 |
| 85 |
NULU Toasted Straight Bourbon – Single Barrel Select for Party Source (Barrel B31T) |
POOR |
$145 |
| 88 |
New Riff Single Barrel Bourbon – Justin’s House of Bourbon (Barrel # 16-3293) |
BEST |
$50 |
| 83 |
New Riff Single Barrel Bourbon – Westport Whiskey & Wine Barrel Pick (Barrel # 16-2003) |
OK |
$50 |
| 87 |
Three Boys Farm Distillery Hand Filled 7 Yr Bourbon |
POOR |
$145 |
| 86 |
Barrel House Rock Castle Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Barrel Proof (Batch 11) |
POOR |
$85 |
| 87 |
Boone County 8 Yr Single Barrel Wheated Bourbon (Barrel BCW43) |
OK |
$99 |
| 90 |
Boone County 7 Yr Single Barrel Wheated Bourbon (Barrel BCW42) |
GOOD |
$85 |
| 84 |
Neely Family Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon (Barrel # 80) |
POOR |
$80 |
| 87 |
Yellowstone Kentucky Straight Bourbon – Hand Picked Collection – Single Barrel (Total Wine) |
GOOD |
$75 |
| 83 |
Bluegrass Distillers Kentucky Straight Bourbon – Wheated Single Barrel |
OK |
$50 |
| 92 |
Michter’s Limited Release Barrel Strength Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$250 |
| 90 |
Four Roses Limited Edition Bourbon 2019 Release |
POOR |
$140 |
| 90 |
Bardstown Bourbon Discovery Series # 4 |
OK |
$130 |
| 91 |
Willett Family Estate Bottled Single Barrel Straight Kentucky Bourbon – Barrel No. 6601 – 6 Yr |
OK |
$135 |
| 89 |
Barrell Bourbon |
POOR |
$250 |
| 83 |
Sagamore Spirit Distiller’s Select Tequila Finish Rye Whiskey |
OK |
$58 |
| 87 |
Sagamore Spirit Distiller’s Select Manhattan Finished Rye Whiskey |
GOOD |
$69 |
| 84 |
Sagamore Spirit Cask Strength Straight Rye Whiskey |
OK |
$63 |
| 86 |
Sagamore Spirit Double Oak Straight Rye Whiskey |
GOOD |
$52 |
| 85 |
Early Times Bottled In Bond Bourbon |
BEST |
$19 |
| 87 |
Bomberger’s Declaration Kentucky Straight Bourbon, 2020 Release |
OK |
$90 |
| 86 |
Shenk’s Homestead Sour Mash Whiskey, 2020 Release |
OK |
$80 |
| 86 |
Starlight Carl T Huber’s Single Barrel Port-Finished Bourbon (Total Wine) |
GOOD |
$50 |
| 88 |
Old 55 Single Barrel Bourbon |
BEST |
$60 |
| 86 |
Ezra Brooks Distillers Collection Kentucky Straight Bourbon (Westport) |
GOOD |
$50 |
| 86 |
New Riff Maltster Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Made With Malted Wheat |
GOOD |
$55 |
| 87 |
Woodinville Single Barrel Straight Bourbon (Westport Store Pick) |
GOOD |
$75 |
| 88 |
Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel Select Barrel Proof Tennessee Whiskey |
BEST |
$60 |
| 89 |
High West A Midwinter Night’s Dram Act 7, Scene 2 |
OK |
$100 |
| 84 |
Wathen’s Barrel Proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$80 |
| 86 |
New York Distilling 7 Year Rye (SMWS RW3.1 Big, bold, fruity & spicy) |
POOR |
$90 |
| 88 |
NULU 7 Year Rye (Party Source) |
POOR |
$148 |
| 87 |
Wild Turkey Rare Breed Barrel Proof Rye, First Release |
BEST |
$65 |
| 86 |
Pinhook Tiz Rye Time 4 Year Straight Rye Whiskey (Westport Whiskey & Wine) |
GOOD |
$65 |
| 84 |
M.B. Roland Kentucky Straight Rye, Batch 3 |
OK |
$55 |
| 82 |
Castle & Key Restoration Rye Batch 1 |
OK |
$40 |
| 90 |
New Riff Single Barrel Bourbon, Barrel # 16-2786 BBQ Cocoa Puffs |
BEST |
$60 |
| 89 |
Westland American Single Malt Whiskey Cask No 2781 |
GOOD |
$125 |
| 87 |
Westland American Single Malt Whiskey Garryana 2020 5th Edition |
OK |
$150 |
| 86 |
Westland American Single Malt Whiskey Garryana 2019 Edition 4|1 |
POOR |
$165 |
| 75 |
Breuckelen Single Malt 2013 (SMWS 142.1 Made in New York, New York) |
POOR |
$110 |
| 77 |
McKenzie Finger Lakes Rye (SMWS RW2.1 Out of the ordinary – in a very good way!) |
POOR |
$100 |
| 86 |
McKenzie Finger Lakes Bourbon (SMWS B6.1 Ginger-spiced sponge) |
POOR |
$90 |
| 87 |
Knob Creek 12 Yr Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
BEST |
$59 |
| 84 |
Elijah Craig Toasted Barrel Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
OK |
$50 |
| 85 |
Penelope Bourbon Four Grain Straight Bourbon Whiskey – Rosé Cask Finish |
GOOD |
$65 |
| 84 |
Barrell Craft Spirits Rye – Cask Strength – Batch 1 |
POOR |
$85 |
| 92 |
Maker’s Mark Private Select – Bayway World of Liquor Store Pick #4 |
BEST |
$75 |
| 90 |
Four Roses OESQ Cask Strength Single Barrel – Gordon’s Pick |
BEST |
$80 |
| 87 |
New Riff Single Barrel Rye |
BEST |
$65 |
| 86 |
Pinhook Straight Bourbon Whiskey (Gordon’s Store Pick) |
OK |
$70 |
| 90 |
Elijah Craig 12 Yr Barrel Proof Bourbon (Batch C920) |
BEST |
$65 |
| 85 |
Balcones Single Malt Texas Whisky 4 Yr (Single/Double-Cask Nation) |
GOOD |
$85 |
| 90 |
Smoke Wagon Straight Bourbon 8 Yr Bayway Liquors Private Barrel |
BEST |
$70 |
| 93 |
Booker’s Bourbon Teresa’s Batch 2019-01 |
BEST |
$90 |
| 90 |
Maker’s Mark Limited Edition 1995 – Gold Wax & Label Japanese Edition |
POOR |
$450 |
| 91 |
Wild Turkey 12 Yr 101 – 1990’s Japanese Release |
POOR |
$250 |
| 87 |
Wild Turkey 8 Yr 101 – USA Release 1965 |
POOR |
$500 |
| 86 |
Wild Turkey 8 Yr 101 – 1980’s Japanese Release |
POOR |
$150 |
| 88 |
Wild Turkey Tradition Bourbon – 1994 |
POOR |
$200 |
| 80 |
Old Fitzgerald Prime Bourbon |
OK |
$18 |
| 93 |
Willett Family Estate Bottled Single Barrel Straight Kentucky Bourbon – Barrel No. 2019 – 6 Yr |
POOR |
$325 |
| 88 |
Weller Full Proof Bourbon |
OK |
$98 |
| 91 |
Blood Oath Pact No. 6 |
OK |
$108 |
| 89 |
Uncle Nearest 1856 Premium Whiskey |
BEST |
$57 |
| 86 |
Penelope Bourbon Four Grain Straight Bourbon Whiskey – PX Finish |
N/A |
N/A |
| 89 |
Penelope Bourbon Four Grain Straight Bourbon Whiskey- Oloroso Finish |
N/A |
N/A |
| 88 |
Penelope Bourbon Barrel Strength Four Grain Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
BEST |
$57 |
| 85 |
Penelope Bourbon Four Grain Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
BEST |
$32 |
| 90 |
Taconic Distillery Double Barrel Maple Bourbon, Release #5 |
BEST |
$60 |
| 76 |
Limestone Branch 100% Malted Rye (Toddy’s Liquors Store Pick) |
POOR |
$60 |
| 82 |
Wilderness Trail Settlers’ Select Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Rye – Barrel 15D17 |
POOR |
$64 |
| 88 |
Pinhook Single Barrel Straight Bourbon (Justin’s House of Bourbon) |
BEST |
$50 |
| 89 |
Four Roses Small Batch Select Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
BEST |
$55 |
| 86 |
Peerless 3 Year Single Barrel Rye “Orange Blossom” |
POOR |
$110 |
| 84 |
Traverse City Straight Bourbon XXX Whiskey |
GOOD |
$33 |
| 74 |
Town Branch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$30 |
| 79 |
Widow Jane Rye Mash Oak and Applewood-Aged Whiskey |
POOR |
$43 |
| 93 |
Thomas H Handy Sazerac Rye 2016 Release |
POOR |
$350 |
| 82 |
Taconic Dutchess Private Reserve Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
OK |
$38 |
| 88 |
Stonecutter Spirits Heritage Cask Whiskey |
BEST |
$61 |
| 80 |
Spring Mill Bourbon |
OK |
$30 |
| 85 |
Shays’ Rebellion American Whiskey |
OK |
$120 |
| 84 |
Sazerac Rye |
GOOD |
$40 |
| 88 |
Rock Hill Farms Single Barrel Bourbon |
BEST |
$40 |
| 82 |
Trail’s End Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$47 |
| 78 |
Very Old Barton |
POOR |
$24 |
| 86 |
W.L. Weller 12 Yr |
BEST |
$40 |
| 91 |
Wild Turkey Master’s Keep “Revival” |
POOR |
$140 |
| 89 |
Wild Turkey Master’s Keep “Decades” |
POOR |
$130 |
| 80 |
Russell’s Reserve 10 Yr Small Batch Bourbon |
OK |
$36 |
| 85 |
Wild Turkey Rare Breed Barrel Proof Straight Bourbon |
BEST |
$40 |
| 88 |
Wild Turkey Kentucky Spirit 8 Yr Single Barrel |
BEST |
$45 |
| 90 |
Wild Turkey Diamond Anniversary |
OK |
$125 |
| 83 |
Redemption Wheated Bourbon |
OK |
$46 |
| 91 |
Redemption Rye 8 Yr (Batch 1) |
GOOD |
$90 |
| 91 |
Rebel Yell 10 Yr Single Barrel Bourbon, Barrel # 5132354 |
BEST |
$75 |
| 79 |
Ragtime Rye |
POOR |
$45 |
| 81 |
Pure Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
OK |
$35 |
| 85 |
Pinhook Bourbon-N-Rye Straight Rye Whiskey Lot #1 |
BEST |
$35 |
| 94 |
Parker’s Heritage Bourbon Whiskey 6th Edition – 2012 |
POOR |
$500 |
| 89 |
Orphan Barrel Rhetoric 23 Yr |
POOR |
$150 |
| 88 |
Old Potrero Hotaling’s Single Malt Rye 18 Yr |
POOR |
$200 |
| 91 |
Old Potrero Hotaling’s Single Malt Rye 16 Yr |
POOR |
$165 |
| 81 |
Old Potrero 18th Century Style Single Malt Rye |
POOR |
$60 |
| 83 |
Old Maysville Club Straight Rye Malt Bottled In Bond |
OK |
$65 |
| 86 |
Old Fitzgerald Very Special 12 Yr |
POOR |
$140 |
| 88 |
Old Carter Straight Rye, Batch 1 |
N/A |
N/A |
| 82 |
Noble Oak Double Oak Bourbon |
OK |
$35 |
| 85 |
Wilderness Trail 2018 Bottled In Bond 4 Yr Wheated Barrel 14D07 |
GOOD |
$46 |
| 87 |
Willett Family Estate Single Barrel Rye |
BEST |
$45 |
| 90 |
Willett 5 Yr Single Barrel Bourbon, Lion’s Share, Barrel # 405 |
N/A |
N/A |
| 73 |
Minor Case Straight Rye Whiskey Sherry Finish |
POOR |
$50 |
| 76 |
Michter’s US 1 Unblended American Whiskey |
POOR |
$46 |
| 83 |
Michter’s US 1 Original Sour Mash Small Batch |
OK |
$46 |
| 82 |
Michter’s US 1 Bourbon |
OK |
$36 |
| 90 |
Michter’s 10 Yr Single Barrel Straight Rye |
POOR |
$300 |
| 85 |
Michter’s 10 Yr Single Barrel Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$180 |
| 89 |
McCarthy’s Single Barrel 3 Yr Single Malt Cask Strength for Hard Water |
BEST |
$80 |
| 86 |
McCarthy’s Oregon Single Malt 2015 W15-02 |
BEST |
$40 |
| 93 |
William Heavenhill Single Barrel 14 Yr Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$250 |
| 85 |
Little Book Chapter One – 2017 Release – The Easy |
GOOD |
$75 |
| 84 |
Koval Single Barrel Rye Whiskey |
OK |
$60 |
| 82 |
Koval Single Barrel Oat Whiskey |
OK |
$51 |
| 82 |
Koval Single Barrel Four Grain Whiskey |
OK |
$51 |
| 85 |
Koval Single Barrel Bourbon Whiskey |
GOOD |
$51 |
| 86 |
Knob Creek Cask Strength Rye |
OK |
$70 |
| 97 |
William Larue Weller Kentucky Straight Bourbon 2016 Release |
POOR |
$500 |
| 88 |
Maker’s Mark Private Select Winter 2016 |
GOOD |
$70 |
| 83 |
Maker’s Mark Cask Strength Bourbon Whisky |
OK |
$56 |
| 89 |
Jeptha Creed Bourbon – 1.5 Yr Rye Mash Bill Cask 16K03A/16-005A |
N/A |
N/A |
| 83 |
Jefferson’s Reserve Very Old |
OK |
$48 |
| 72 |
Jefferson’s Reserve Groth Cask Finish |
POOR |
$66 |
| 90 |
Jefferson’s Ocean-Aged Bourbon Cask Strength |
GOOD |
$86 |
| 79 |
Ironweed 4 Yr Malt Batch 50 |
N/A |
N/A |
| 85 |
Ironweed 4 Yr Cask Strength Malt Batch 50 |
N/A |
N/A |
| 83 |
Ironweed 3 Yr Cask Strength Bourbon |
N/A |
N/A |
| 75 |
Iron Smoke Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$50 |
| 70 |
I.W. Harper Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$32 |
| 86 |
I.W. Harper 15 Yr Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
OK |
$70 |
| 91 |
Hillrock Estate Solera Aged Bourbon, Sauternes Finish |
GOOD |
$100 |
| 88 |
Hillrock Estate Double Cask Rye Porto Finish |
OK |
$90 |
| 90 |
Hillrock Estate Double Cask Rye Oloroso Finish |
GOOD |
$90 |
| 89 |
Hillrock Estate Double Cask Rye Madeira Finish |
OK |
$90 |
| 86 |
High West Yippee-Ki-Yay |
OK |
$80 |
| 69 |
High West Valley Tan Utah Whiskey |
NO |
$50 |
| 87 |
High West Double Rye, Scotch Cask Finish |
BEST |
$55 |
| 91 |
High West A Midwinter Night’s Dram Act 6, Scene 4 |
GOOD |
$100 |
| 89 |
High West A Midwinter Night’s Dram Act 4, Scene 1 |
GOOD |
$70 |
| 82 |
High West 14 Yr Light Whiskey |
POOR |
$100 |
| 95 |
George T. Stagg Kentucky Straight Bourbon 2016 |
POOR |
$475 |
| 71 |
Garrison Brothers Single Barrel Bourbon Exclusive Bottling for Astor Wines |
POOR |
$110 |
| 92 |
Four Roses OESF Cask Strength Single Barrel |
BEST |
$75 |
| 92 |
Four Roses OESQ Cask Strength Single Barrel |
BEST |
$75 |
| 89 |
Willett Kentucky Straight Bourbon 6 Yr, Single Barrel Storm Dollar for The Silver Dollar |
N/A |
N/A |
| 87 |
George A. Dickel Bourbon (SMWS B5.1 Sheer brilliance) |
POOR |
$225 |
| 90 |
Four Roses OBSQ Cask Strength Single Barrel |
BEST |
$72 |
| 93 |
Four Roses OBSK Cask Strength Single Barrel |
BEST |
$74 |
| 95 |
Four Roses 2017 Limited Edition Al Young 50th Anniversary Small Batch |
POOR |
$589 |
| 77 |
Ezra Brooks Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$15 |
| 91 |
Elijah Craig 12 Yr Barrel Proof (Batch B517) |
BEST |
$60 |
| 95 |
Elijah Craig 12 Yr Barrel Proof Release 11 (Batch B516) |
BEST |
$65 |
| 68 |
Duke Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
NO |
$34 |
| 83 |
David Nicholson Reserve Bourbon (Black Label) |
GOOD |
$33 |
| 86 |
Courage & Conviction Single Malt (Bourbon-barrel matured) |
N/A |
N/A |
| 84 |
Coppersea Bonticou Crag Straight Rye Malt Whisky |
POOR |
$75 |
| 91 |
Van Winkle Family Reserve 17 Yr |
POOR |
$5500 |
| 94 |
Colonel E.H. Taylor Barrel Proof Straight Bourbon Batch 3 (2014) |
BEST |
$90 |
| 84 |
Bulleit Frontier 10 Yr Bourbon |
OK |
$47 |
| 89 |
Bulleit Barrel Strength Bourbon Batch 4 |
BEST |
$59 |
| 86 |
Westward Astor Pick Single Cask Single Malt |
GOOD |
$100 |
| 88 |
Maker’s Mark Private Select RC6 |
GOOD |
$70 |
| 86 |
St George Baller Single Malt Whiskey |
BEST |
$75 |
| 87 |
High Wire New Southern Revival Rye |
BEST |
$60 |
| 90 |
George A. Dickel Bourbon (Pursuit Series Episode 015) |
OK |
$110 |
| 92 |
George A. Dickel Bourbon (Pursuit Series Episode 014) |
OK |
$150 |
| 91 |
George A. Dickel Bourbon (Pursuit Series Episode 013) |
OK |
$110 |
| 89 |
George A. Dickel Bourbon (Pursuit Series Episode 012) |
GOOD |
$75 |
| 92 |
George A. Dickel Bourbon (Pursuit Series Episode 011) |
BEST |
$75 |
| 83 |
Finger Lakes Distilling (Pursuit Series Episode 010) |
OK |
$65 |
| 88 |
George A. Dickel Bourbon (Pursuit Series Episode 009) |
POOR |
$110 |
| 90 |
George A. Dickel Bourbon (Pursuit Series Episode 008) |
BEST |
$75 |
| 82 |
Bower Hill Barrell Reserve Bourbon |
OK |
$42 |
| 89 |
Blood Oath Pact No. 3 |
OK |
$100 |
| 82 |
Blood Oath Pact No. 2 |
POOR |
$100 |
| 86 |
Black Saddle 12 Yr Old Straight Bourbon |
GOOD |
$55 |
| 85 |
Black Button Double Barrel Four Grain Straight Bourbon |
N/A |
N/A |
| 86 |
Black Button Cask Strength Bourbon Batch 1 |
N/A |
N/A |
| 81 |
Black Button Bourbon Barrel # 575 |
N/A |
N/A |
| 85 |
Black Button Bourbon Barrel # 574 |
N/A |
N/A |
| 82 |
Black Button Bourbon Barrel # 566 |
N/A |
N/A |
| 87 |
Black Button Bourbon Barrel # 518 |
GOOD |
$68 |
| 87 |
Berkshire Bourbon Smoke and Peat |
BEST |
$60 |
| 81 |
Beanball Bourbon |
OK |
$33 |
| 90 |
Michter’s US 1 Single Barrel Fort Nelson Reserve Straight Rye |
POOR |
$150 |
| 89 |
Woodford Reserve 2019 Master’s Collection Chocolate Malted Rye Bourbon |
POOR |
$135 |
| 84 |
Heaven Hill 7 Yr Bottled In Bond Bourbon |
GOOD |
$45 |
| 82 |
Journeyman Corsets, Whips & Whiskey, Barrel BWW-17-2197 |
OK |
$48 |
| 83 |
Journeyman Corsets, Whips & Whiskey, Barrel BWW-17-2192 |
GOOD |
$48 |
| 84 |
Journeyman Corsets, Whips & Whiskey, Barrel BWW-17-2191 |
GOOD |
$48 |
| 85 |
Journeyman Corsets, Whips & Whiskey, Barrel CWW-17-1868 |
BEST |
$48 |
| 83 |
Journeyman Corsets, Whips & Whiskey, Barrel CWW-17-1867 |
GOOD |
$48 |
| 79 |
Journeyman Featherbone Bourbon |
POOR |
$38 |
| 80 |
Journeyman Last Feather Rye Single Barrel Store Pick (Georgetown Wine & Spirits) |
OK |
$40 |
| 94 |
William Heavenhill 12 Yr Barrel Proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$250 |
| 89 |
WhistlePig Old World 12 Yr Cask Finish Rye – Saratoga Whiskey Club Bespoke Blend |
POOR |
$110 |
| 94 |
Thomas H Handy Sazerac Rye 2019 Release |
POOR |
$400 |
| 96 |
George T. Stagg Kentucky Straight Bourbon 2019 |
POOR |
$400 |
| 95 |
William Larue Weller Kentucky Straight Bourbon 2019 Release |
POOR |
$400 |
| 89 |
Michter’s US 1 Toasted Barrel Finish Sour Mash Whiskey |
OK |
$100 |
| 85 |
Legent Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
BEST |
$35 |
| 85 |
Black Button American Straight Whiskey Batch 1 |
BEST |
$36 |
| 76 |
Four Fights Bowers Distiller’s Cut Cask Strength Single Barrel Bourbon |
POOR |
$60 |
| 89 |
Milwaukee’s Club 28th Anniversary Double Oaked Single Barrel American Style Whiskey |
POOR |
$170 |
| 92 |
Michter’s US 1 Toasted Barrel Finish Rye |
BEST |
$75 |
| 90 |
WhistlePig Farm 18 Yr Double Malt Straight Rye Whiskey |
POOR |
$399 |
| 83 |
WhistlePig Farm PiggyBack 6 Yr Rye |
GOOD |
$45 |
| 86 |
WhistlePig Farm Old World Straight Rye 12 Yr |
POOR |
$130 |
| 91 |
WhistlePig Farm Estate Oak Rye 15 Yr |
POOR |
$199 |
| 84 |
WhistlePig Farm Farmstock Crop No. 003 Rye |
POOR |
$70 |
| 91 |
WhistlePig Farm The Boss Hog Rye 5th Edition – The Spirit of Mauve 13 Yr |
POOR |
$449 |
| 94 |
Colonel E.H. Taylor Four Grain |
POOR |
$300 |
| 93 |
Four Roses OESK Barrel Strength Elliott’s Select 2016 |
POOR |
$350 |
| 86 |
Hancock’s President’s Reserve Single Barrel Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$85 |
| 89 |
Little Book Chapter Two – 2018 Release – Noe Simple Task |
GOOD |
$100 |
| 91 |
Lock Stock & Barrel 18 Yr Rye |
POOR |
$230 |
| 83 |
Second Glance American Whiskey |
GOOD |
$40 |
| 85 |
The Burning Chair Bourbon |
GOOD |
$50 |
| 86 |
Lip Service Rye |
BEST |
$35 |
| 94 |
William Larue Weller Kentucky Straight Bourbon 2018 Release |
POOR |
$400 |
| 84 |
Yellowstone Limited #3-Char Wine Cask Finish Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$100 |
| 88 |
Bardstown Phifer Pavitt Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon Finish Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$125 |
| 87 |
Sagamore Spirit Port Finish Rye Whiskey |
BEST |
$65 |
| 85 |
Elijah Craig Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
BEST |
$28 |
| 80 |
Evan Williams Bottled In Bond Kentucky Bourbon |
OK |
$18 |
| 71 |
Mellow Corn |
POOR |
$15 |
| 85 |
Iron Smoke Single Barrel Straight Bourbon Whiskey – Lisa’s Liquor Barn Store Pick |
GOOD |
$60 |
| 90 |
1792 Full Proof Bourbon Gordon’s Barrel Selection 2019 |
BEST |
$45 |
| 84 |
Balcones Texas Rye |
GOOD |
$40 |
| 86 |
McKenzie Bottled In Bond Bourbon (Wheated) |
BEST |
$42 |
| 83 |
Infuse Heresy Rye Whiskey |
GOOD |
$30 |
| 89 |
Old Ezra 7 Yr Barrel Strength Bourbon |
BEST |
$45 |
| 97 |
George T. Stagg Kentucky Straight Bourbon 2018 |
POOR |
$400 |
| 89 |
Willett Family Estate Small Batch Rye 4 Yr |
BEST |
$60 |
| 84 |
Catskill Straight Rye Whiskey |
GOOD |
$43 |
| 86 |
Black Maple Hill Oregon Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$90 |
| 86 |
New Riff Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
BEST |
$40 |
| 89 |
Colonel E.H. Taylor Straight Rye |
GOOD |
$80 |
| 89 |
Collabor&tion Brandy Barrel Finish Bourbon Bottle # 1776 |
POOR |
$125 |
| 86 |
Cedar Ridge Single Malt Whiskey |
BEST |
$60 |
| 89 |
Eagle Rare 17 Yr Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$400 |
| 82 |
Eagle Rare 10 Yr Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
OK |
$30 |
| 87 |
Catoctin Creek Roundstone Rye Single Barrel Maple Finish 18E13 |
OK |
$99 |
| 86 |
Catoctin Creek Roundstone Rye Single Barrel Cask Proof 18E17 |
POOR |
$99 |
| 84 |
Catoctin Creek Roundstone Rye Distillers Edition Single Barrel 19G01 |
OK |
$46 |
| 82 |
Catoctin Creek Roundstone Rye Single Barrel Batch 18H33 |
OK |
$40 |
| 88 |
Catoctin Creek Roundstone Rye Cask Proof Brandy Finish |
OK |
$99 |
| 89 |
Baker’s Kentucky Straight Bourbon 7 Yr |
BEST |
$50 |
| 86 |
Westland Sherry Wood American Single Malt |
GOOD |
$80 |
| 84 |
Westland Peated American Single Malt |
OK |
$80 |
| 83 |
Westland American Oak American Single Malt |
GOOD |
$70 |
| 88 |
Westland American Single Malt Single Cask for Astor Wines (Cask 118) |
BEST |
$100 |
| 90 |
Westland American Single Malt Cask # 2479 (K&L) – Sherry |
BEST |
$110 |
| 80 |
Stranahan’s Colorado Whiskey (Yellow Label) |
OK |
$50 |
| 81 |
Templeton Rye |
OK |
$29 |
| 86 |
Jefferson’s Ocean-Aged Bourbon |
OK |
$75 |
| 93 |
Orphan Barrel Rhetoric 22 Yr Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
GOOD |
$120 |
| 93 |
Pappy Van Winkle’s 23 Yr Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$2300 |
| 94 |
Pappy Van Winkle’s 20 Yr Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$1500 |
| 81 |
Maker’s 46 Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky |
OK |
$35 |
| 83 |
Blade & Bow Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
OK |
$55 |
| 89 |
Belle Meade Single Barrel Cask Strength Bourbon |
GOOD |
$75 |
| 79 |
Old Bardstown 4 Yr Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$19 |
| 78 |
Old Bardstown Kentucky Straight Bourbon Bottled in Bond |
POOR |
$19 |
| 82 |
Rabbit Hole Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey |
POOR |
$50 |
| 90 |
Boone County Distilling 12 Yr Single Barrel Justin’s House of Bourbon Store Pick |
GOOD |
$89 |
| 78 |
Rabbit Hole Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$50 |
| 90 |
Michter’s Limited Edition Barrel Strength Rye |
BEST |
$80 |
| 82 |
Whip Saw Rye Whiskey |
OK |
$45 |
| 81 |
Sagamore Spirit Signature Straight Rye Whiskey |
OK |
$40 |
| 76 |
Ironweed Rye Whiskey |
POOR |
$50 |
| 74 |
Rebel Yell Boubon |
POOR |
$13 |
| 77 |
Old Crow Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$11 |
| 83 |
Smooth Ambler Contradiction Bourbon Whiskey |
OK |
$50 |
| 80 |
Smooth Ambler Old Scout 10 Yr Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$52 |
| 88 |
Old Forester Statesman Bourbon Whiskey |
BEST |
$55 |
| 86 |
Henry McKenna 10 Yr Single Barrel Bottled In Bond Bourbon |
BEST |
$35 |
| 79 |
Noah’s Mill Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$42 |
| 88 |
Calumet Farm 12 Yr Bourbon Whiskey |
BEST |
$65 |
| 82 |
Calumet Farm Bourbon Whiskey |
OK |
$45 |
| 79 |
Rowan’s Creek Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$32 |
| 82 |
Old Grand Dad Bonded Bourbon |
OK |
$20 |
| 81 |
1792 Small Batch Bourbon |
OK |
$26 |
| 83 |
Larceny Bourbon |
GOOD |
$25 |
| 68 |
McKenzie Rye |
NO |
$42 |
| 75 |
McKenzie Bourbon |
POOR |
$42 |
| 89 |
High West Bourye 2015 |
GOOD |
$100 |
| 73 |
Hudson Manhattan Rye Whiskey |
POOR |
$78 |
| 72 |
Hudson Baby Bourbon |
POOR |
$66 |
| 85 |
New Riff Single Barrel Bourbon |
GOOD |
$50 |
| 67 |
Wild Turkey 101 |
MIXER |
$19 |
| 78 |
Old Forester |
POOR |
$23 |
| 82 |
Weller Special Reserve |
OK |
$25 |
| 84 |
Old Pogue Master’s Select Bourbon |
POOR |
$90 |
| 82 |
Weller Antique 107 |
OK |
$30 |
| 79 |
Bulleit Bourbon |
POOR |
$30 |
| 80 |
Bulleit Rye |
OK |
$30 |
| 89 |
Elmer T Lee Single Barrel Sour Mash Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$130 |
| 83 |
Four Roses Single Barrel Bourbon |
GOOD |
$33 |
| 79 |
Rittenhouse Rye Bottled In Bond |
POOR |
$23 |
| 87 |
Russell’s Reserve Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Rye |
BEST |
$60 |
| 83 |
Russell’s Reserve Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
OK |
$46 |
| 94 |
Pappy Van Winkle’s 15 Yr Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$800 |
| 87 |
Old Rip Van Winkle 10 Yr Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$500 |
| 69 |
Four Roses Kentucky Straight Bourbon (Yellow Label) |
MIXER |
$15 |
| 96 |
George T. Stagg Kentucky Straight Bourbon 2017 |
POOR |
$450 |
| 76 |
Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon |
POOR |
$24 |
| 74 |
Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$24 |
| 79 |
Bernheim Original Wheat Whiskey |
POOR |
$27 |
| 86 |
Booker’s Bourbon |
GOOD |
$48 |
| 79 |
Maker’s Mark Bourbon Whisky |
POOR |
$22 |
| 85 |
Blackened Straight American Whiskey |
GOOD |
$70 |
| 73 |
Cask & Crew Rye Batch #4 |
POOR |
$25 |
| 82 |
Catskill Most Righteous Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$60 |
| 82 |
Bootlegger 21 New York Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$55 |
| 93 |
Van Winkle Special Reserve 12 Yr “Lot B” |
POOR |
$600 |
| 90 |
Old Fitzgerald 11 Yr Bottled in Bond |
POOR |
$200 |
| 79 |
77 Whiskey – Local Rye & Corn |
POOR |
$45 |
| 77 |
2nd Chance Wheat Whiskey |
POOR |
$55 |
| 87 |
1792 Port Finish |
BEST |
$40 |
| 89 |
1792 225th Anniversary Bourbon |
BEST |
$36 |
| 96 |
William Larue Weller Kentucky Straight Bourbon 2017 Release |
POOR |
$500 |
| 90 |
Old Forester 1920 |
BEST |
$60 |
| 91 |
Angel’s Envy Rye |
GOOD |
$95 |
| 84 |
Michter’s US 1 Single Barrel Straight Rye |
GOOD |
$43 |
| 90 |
Colonel E.H. Taylor Single Barrel |
BEST |
$55 |
| 87 |
Angel’s Envy Bourbon |
BEST |
$50 |
| 87 |
High West Double Rye |
BEST |
$30 |
| 84 |
Basil Hayden’s 8 Yr |
GOOD |
$35 |
| 81 |
M.B. Roland Kentucky Straight Bourbon Barrel #38 |
POOR |
$46 |
| 90 |
Four Roses Super Premium Platinum Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$250 |
| 93 |
Elijah Craig 12 Yr Barrel Proof Release 2 |
BEST |
$60 |
| 89 |
Elijah Craig 18 Yr Single Barrel (#4318) |
POOR |
$200 |
| 89 |
Stagg Jr Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
BEST |
$39 |
| 90 |
Westland Peat Week Release 5 (2018) |
BEST |
$100 |
| 91 |
Westland Peat Week Release 4 (2017) – Spinther |
BEST |
$100 |
| 85 |
High West American Prairie Bourbon |
BEST |
$38 |
| 96 |
Angel’s Envy Cask Strength Bourbon 2017 |
GOOD |
$200 |
| 90 |
Rebel Yell 10 Yr Single Barrel Bourbon, Barrel # 5132349 |
BEST |
$75 |
| 88 |
Pikesville Straight Rye Whiskey |
BEST |
$45 |
| 85 |
Old Grand Dad 114 Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
BEST |
$25 |
| 88 |
Maker’s Mark Private Select Bourbon Spring 2017 |
GOOD |
$70 |
| 77 |
Knob Creek 100 Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$26 |
| 86 |
Hillrock Estate Single Malt OPX10 |
GOOD |
$100 |
| 88 |
High West Double Rye Barrel Select 2017 |
BEST |
$50 |
| 94 |
Colonel E.H. Taylor Barrel Proof Straight Bourbon 2017 |
BEST |
$80 |
| 80 |
Balcones Texas Single Malt |
POOR |
$80 |
| 93 |
Four Roses OESV Cask Strength Single Barrel Bourbon (Toddy’s Barrel Pick) |
BEST |
$75 |
| 88 |
Willett Family Estate Single Barrel Rye 3 Yr |
BEST |
$35 |
| 85 |
Willett Pot Still Reserve Bourbon |
BEST |
$40 |
| 89 |
High West Campfire |
BEST |
$59 |
| 92 |
Redemption Rye 8 Yr (Batch 2) |
BEST |
$90 |
| 90 |
Hillrock Estate Solera Aged Bourbon, Oloroso Finish Barrel # 106 |
BEST |
$80 |
| 90 |
Kentucky Owl 11 Yr Straight Rye |
OK |
$130 |
| 65 |
Jim Beam Rye |
MIXER |
$23 |
| 84 |
Woodford Reserve Distiller’s Select Bourbon |
GOOD |
$36 |
| 82 |
Woodford Reserve Rye |
OK |
$40 |
| 86 |
Wyoming Whiskey Outryder |
GOOD |
$65 |
| 84 |
Yankee Bourbon Batch 8 |
OK |
$60 |
| 82 |
Yankee Bourbon Batch 9 |
POOR |
$60 |
| 83 |
Yankee Rye Batch 7 |
OK |
$60 |
| 83 |
Yellowstone Select Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
OK |
$50 |
| 79 |
Journeyman Silver Cross Whiskey |
POOR |
$50 |
| 85 |
Peerless Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey, First Release |
POOR |
$110 |
| 97 |
William Larue Weller Kentucky Straight Bourbon 2015 Release |
POOR |
$500 |
| 91 |
Blood Oath Pact No. 4 |
OK |
$109 |
| 83 |
Black Button Small-Batch Four-Grain Straight Bourbon, Batch 5 |
OK |
$50 |
| 92 |
1792 Full Proof Bourbon Gordon’s Barrel Selection 2017 |
BEST |
$45 |
| 88 |
Black Button Port Finished Single Barrel Bourbon Batch 326 |
POOR |
$200 |
| 91 |
High West A Midwinter Night’s Dram Act 5, Scene 8 |
GOOD |
$100 |
| 90 |
Blanton’s Single Barrel Bourbon |
BEST |
$60 |
| 80 |
Cleveland Bourbon |
POOR |
$50 |
| 77 |
Cleveland Underground Sugar Maple Wood Finished Bourbon |
POOR |
$45 |
| 80 |
Cleveland Underground Black Cherry Wood Finished Bourbon |
OK |
$45 |
| 78 |
Cleveland Underground Apple Wood Finished Bourbon |
POOR |
$45 |