Points | Name | Value | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 90 | Caol Ila 9Yr Tokaji Wine Cask Finish (Murray McDavid Benchmark Series) | BEST | $120 |
| 95 | Allt-A-Bhainne 25 Yr Single Malt Mission Gold (Murray McDavid, Cask # 187841) | POOR | $425 |
| 88 | Murray McDavid Peatside 6 Yr Blended Malt – “The Vatting” – Distilled 2010 | BEST | $90 |
| 89 | Craigellachie 2007 8 Yr Koval Rye Finish (Murray McDavid) | BEST | $68 |
| 88 | Craigellachie 12 Yr Tawny Port (Murray McDavid) | GOOD | $122 |
| 90 | Murray McDavid “Mystery Malt” Safe Haven 6 Yr 2014 | BEST | $69 |
| 88 | Dailuaine 12 Yr Benchmark 2009 (Murray McDavid) | GOOD | $110 |
| 84 | Murray McDavid North British 13 Yr Single Grain | OK | $80 |
| 89 | Murray McDavid Righ Seumas II 12YR Crafted Blend | BEST | $79 |
| 87 | Murray McDavid Peated Irish Whiskey 12 Yr | BEST | $80 |