Points | Name | Value | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 92 | Tomatin 1994 26 Yr (Dramfool) | OK | $230 |
| 93 | Tomatin 1988 Tawny Port – 27 Yr | GOOD | $185 |
| 90 | Tomatin 2002 16 Yr (Gordon & MacPhail Connoisseurs Choice) | GOOD | $145 |
| 88 | Tomatin 31 Yr (SMWS 11.41 Smoke, mirrors & honey traps) | POOR | $585 |
| 91 | Tomatin 30 Yr Batch 1 | POOR | $400 |
| 84 | Tomatin 15 Yr Moscatel | POOR | $140 |
| 86 | Tomatin 10 Yr (1970’s – Imported to USA in 1998) | POOR | $170 |
| 88 | Tomatin Cask Strength Single Malt Scotch | BEST | $99 |
| 87 | Tomatin 17 Yr Single Malt Scotch (for The Whisky Plus) | BEST | $94 |
| 80 | Tomatin Legacy | OK | $33 |
| 86 | Tomatin Cù Bòcan | BEST | $52 |
| 89 | Tomatin 23 (Old Malt Cask) | N/A | N/A |
| 88 | Tomatin 10 Yr Chilean Red Wine Cask (Cadenhead’s Warehouse) | BEST | $50 |
| 91 | Tomatin 10 Yr Bourbon Cask Distillery Exclusive | BEST | $95 |
| 85 | Tomatin 12 Yr French Oak | BEST | $40 |
| 82 | Tomatin 12 Yr | OK | $30 |
| 87 | Tomatin 18 Yr Oloroso Sherry | BEST | $80 |
| 84 | Tomatin 14 Yr Portwood | GOOD | $59 |
| 91 | Tomatin 16 Yr Distillery Exclusive Single Cask Pedro Ximenez | BEST | $125 |