PointsNameValuePrice
91 Caol Ila 9 Yr (Lady of the Glen) BEST $100
88 Blair Athol 10 Yr (Lady of the Glen) – Limited Edition Rare Cask BEST $100
86 Glen Spey 10 Yr (Dalgety) GOOD $100
90 Caol Ila 9Yr Tokaji Wine Cask Finish (Murray McDavid Benchmark Series) BEST $120
85 Caol Ila 13 Yr Feis Ile 2024 POOR $230
91 Lagavulin 10 Yr Feis Ile 2024 OK $200
90 Dailuaine 13 Yr (Dram Mor) BEST $100
89 Cardhu 11 Yr Hand Fill Distillery Exclusive OK $145
86 Starward in Collaboration with Lagavulin – Australian Single Malt Whisky OK $130
86 Mortlach 1999 24 Yr (Gordon & MacPhail Cask Strength Connoisseurs Choice Shop Exclusive) POOR $160
91 Clynelish 10 Year Single Cask (SMWS 26.219 A Party Favorite – Burns Night 2024) GOOD $140
86 Dailuaine-Glenlivet 10 Year (Cadenhead Small Batch) OK $126
87 Auchroisk 12 Year (Old Particular) BEST $98
88 Talisker Natural Cask Strength Special Release 2023 OK $150
86 Lady of the Glen 13 Yr (Dufftown, Cask #705315) POOR $186
89 Oban 11 Yr Hand-Filled Distillery Exclusive, Batch # 3, Bourbon Barrel OK $150
90 Glenkinchie 12 Yr Hand Fill Re-Charred Red Wine Cask, Batch 002 GOOD $157
90 Clynelish 15 Yr (Gordon & MacPhail Connoissseur’s Choice) GOOD $150
89 Caol Ila 10 Yr (James Eadie) BEST $98
85 Johnnie Walker 16 Yr Summer Seasonal Blend OK $100
86 Blackadder Raw Cask Inchgower 2009 12 Yr POOR $136
90 Clynelish Hand-Fill Distillery Exclusive, Batch 2023/006, Ex Bourbon GOOD $140
94 Talisker 9 Yr Single Malt Scotch Rejuvenated Red Wine Cask Hand Fill, Batch 2023/03 BEST $150
95 Caol Ila 7 Yr (Fragrant Drops) – Palo Cortado Hogshead # 300564 BEST $96
95 Oban The Macleans Young Teddy Single Malt Scotch OK $250
86 Oban Distillery Exclusive Single Malt Scotch Whisky, Batch # 03 OK $102
87 Talisker x Parley Wilder Seas Single Malt Scotch Whisky BEST $89
89 Clynelish 24 Yr – Refill Bourbon, Distilled 1996 (Thompson Brothers) POOR $240
84 Johnnie Walker Gold Label Reserve Blended Scotch Whisky GOOD $59
94 Linkwood 12 Yr Matured in a Fresh Tokaji Barrel #3001290 (Fragrant Drops) BEST $120
87 Talisker 11 Yr Special Release 2022 GOOD $120
87 Caol Ila 10 Yr (SMWS 53.375 Clambake on the beach) GOOD $135
90 Blair Athol 14 Yr (SMWS 68.93 Supper in the dunnage) GOOD $160
91 Caol Ila 14 Yr Single Malt Scotch (Rare Find, Cask 317325) BEST $125
86 Benrinnes 11 Year Single Malt Scotch (Auld Goonsy’s Malt) GOOD $95
91 Benrinnes 10 Yr (SMWS 36 Rare Release -A Reward For Patience) BEST $115
83 Blair Athol 12 Yr First Edition (DS Tayman) OK $77
89 Caol Ila 8 Yr (SMWS Distillery 53 Rare Release – Throw The Cork Away!) GOOD $135
87 Blair Athol 11 Yr 2007 (Signatory Vintage The Un-Chillfiltered Collection) BEST $95
88 Dailuaine 12 Yr Benchmark 2009 (Murray McDavid) GOOD $110
90 Clynelish 8 Yr (SMWS 26.168 A rustling through the dunes) BEST $115
91 Clynelish 10 Yr (SMWS 26.165 Surprising, inspiring, indulging!) BEST $135
91 Glen Ord 28 Yr (SMWS 77.65 Pure Dead Brilliant) POOR $475
90 Clynelish 19 Yr (Wemyss Malts) GOOD $150
86 Linkwood 12 Yr Single Malt (DS Tayman) GOOD $76
91 Caol Ila 10 Yr (SMWS 53.367 A Green Sea Tapestry) GOOD $145
90 Caol Ila 13 Yr 2004 Hermitage Cask Finish (Gordon & MacPhail) BEST $130
91 Clynelish 20 Yr (Hunter Laing’s Old & Rare) POOR $400
87 Clynelish 20 Yr (Gordon & McPhail- Connoisseurs Choice) POOR $230
85 Blair Athol 20 Yr (Distiller’s Art) POOR $140
85 Blair Athol 11 Yr (SMWS 68.47 Riveting) OK $120
88 Clynelish 9 Yr (SMWS 26.158 Waxing tropical) GOOD $120
80 SIA Blended Scotch Whisky OK $40
82 Copper Dog Speyside Blended Malt Scotch Whisky OK $28
87 Auchroisk 8 Yr (SMWS 95.46 Earthy and Mysterious) BEST $100
89 Cragganmore 18 Yr (SMWS 37.132 Irresistibly tropical) POOR $190
83 Caol Ila 11 Yr (SMWS 53.349 Assertively Coastal) POOR $140
85 Caol Ila 11 Yr 2005 (Gordon & MacPhail) OK $112
86 Linkwood 14 Year Old 2006 (Infrequent Flyers Cask 6144) OK $110
87 Auchroisk 7 Yr (SMWS 95.37 Adventurous African safari) BEST $100
94 Lagavulin 20 Yr Feis Ile 2020 GOOD $240
88 Caol Ila 16 Yr Feis Ile 2020 OK $160
82 Jane Walker by Johnnie Walker OK $35
93 Caol Ila Smoke & Sherry (Cooper’s Choice) BEST $140
93 Caol Ila 13 Yr (Adelphi Selection) BEST $110
90 Blair Athol 10 Yr (SMWS 68.34 Roasty-Toasty-Tasty) BEST $95
93 Benrinnes 22 Yr (SMWS 36.171 A smooth ride) GOOD $180
85 Talisker Distillery Exclusive 2019 OK $104
87 The Singleton of Glen Ord Artisan Distillery Exclusive GOOD $120
85 The Singleton of Glen Ord 15 Yr BEST $65
84 The Singleton of Glen Ord 12 Yr GOOD $40
86 Talisker 57 North GOOD $80
87 Talisker 2005 Distiller’s Edition BEST $92
83 Redemption Wheated Bourbon OK $46
91 Redemption Rye 8 Yr (Batch 1) GOOD $90
89 Orphan Barrel Rhetoric 23 Yr POOR $150
85 Oban 2001 Distiller’s Edition 2016 Release OD 165.FB GOOD $85
79 Mortlach 15 Yr (Gordon & MacPhail) POOR $70
90 Strathmill 1993 25 Yr Ex-Bourbon (Cadenhead Warehouse) BEST $126
89 Strathmill 12-Yr (SMWS 100.14 Boozy basil blueberry) GOOD $125
87 Linkwood 26 Yr (SMWS 39.130 Zing like the ping of a musical string) POOR $235
86 Linkwood 14 Yr (SMWS 39.110 Builders at breaktime) OK $135
91 Lagavulin 35 Yr Dewars Refill Cask POOR $3500
90 Lagavulin 1998 20 Yr Bodega Sherry Butt N/A N/A
91 Lagavulin 1998 19 Yr Bodega Sherry Butt N/A N/A
92 Lagavulin 1997 6 Yr Cask 3865 N/A N/A
89 Lagavulin 1997 21 Yr American Oak N/A N/A
83 Lagavulin 13 Yr N/A N/A
92 Lagavulin 12 Yr 2018 Limited Edition BEST $140
86 Dalwhinnie Distillers Edition 2017 GOOD $80
84 Dalwhinnie 15 Yr GOOD $70
93 Glenlossie 23 Yr (SMWS 46.45 A two-way street) GOOD $195
85 Dailuaine 12 Yr (SMWS 41.89 Tart Flambe) OK $130
85 Cragganmore 12 Yr (SMWS 37.83 An odyssey of flavour) OK $130
84 Cragganmore 12 Yr GOOD $59
82 Clynelish 14 Yr OK $58
87 Clynelish 13 Yr (SMWS 26.121 A real ‘pick-me -up’) GOOD $130
85 Cardhu 18 Yr GOOD $85
95 Lagavulin 1993 25 Yr Sherry Puncheon POOR $1000
94 Lagavulin 1993 24 Yr Sherry Puncheon POOR $1000
88 Port Askaig 15 Yr Sherry Cask BEST $90
86 Caol Ila Distillery Exclusive 2017 OK $120
83 Caol Ila 6 Yr (2012) Refill American Oak N/A N/A
92 Caol Ila 22 Yr 1st Fill Bodega Sherry Butt (1996) N/A N/A
90 Caol Ila 21 Yr 1st Fill Bodega Sherry Butt (1996) N/A N/A
87 Caol Ila 17 Yr Unpeated GOOD $120
86 Caol Ila 12 Yr (2006) 1st Fill American Oak N/A N/A
85 Caol Ila 11 Yr (Gordon & MacPhail for the Whisky Hoop) N/A N/A
84 Bulleit Frontier 10 Yr Bourbon OK $47
89 Bulleit Barrel Strength Bourbon Batch 4 BEST $59
86 Benrinnes 21 Yr (Old Malt Cask – Douglas Laing) POOR $275
84 Benrinnes 20 Yr (SMWS 36.145 Nice day for cricket) POOR $170
77 Benrinnes 13 Yr (SMWS 36.114 Tap-dancing tongue teaser) POOR $130
87 Caol Ila 10 Yr (SMWS 53.310 Kippers in slippers) GOOD $125
85 Teaninich 10 Yr (SMWS 59.59 Spock’s earwax) GOOD $95
90 Clynelish 9 Yr (SMWS 26.132 Krupnik and amaretti) BEST $110
84 Dailuaine 7 Yr (Old Particular Single Cask) GOOD $44
91 Glenlossie 17 Yr (SMWS 46.84 Velvet complexity) GOOD $140
87 Clynelish 23 Yr (Signatory Vintage for The Whisky Hoop) POOR $190
86 Talisker 6 Yr (The Old Malt Cask for The Whisky Hoop) GOOD $85
81 Oban Little Bay OK $65
97 Caol Ila 32 Yr (Distiller’s Art) POOR $450
92 Glenlossie-Glenlivet 1993 24 Yr (Cadenhead’s Warehouse Tasting) OK $190
86 Mortlach 16 Yr Distiller’s Dram GOOD $90
84 Caol Ila 6 Yr (SMWS 53.276 Ein kleiner deutsche samurai) OK $100
87 Johnnie Walker Blue Label POOR $200
82 Mannochmore 8 Yr (SMWS 64.111 Pleasing sweetness, playful heat) POOR $85
88 Lagavulin 11 Yr Offerman Edition BEST $75
92 Caol Ila 10 Yr (Gordon & MacPhail) BEST $95
89 Blair Athol 25 Yr 1988 (Signatory VIntage) OK $140
87 Benrinnes 23 Yr (Cadenhead’s Warehouse) BEST $85
87 Dalwhinnie Winters Frost Game of Thrones House Stark BEST $43
81 The Singleton of Glendullan Select Game of Thrones House Tully OK $33
86 Cardhu Gold Reserve Game of Thrones House Targaryen BEST $45
88 Caol Ila 12 Yr (SMWS 53.287 Ye old medisin) GOOD $130
83 Johnnie Walker Double Black GOOD $43
96 Caol Ila 35 Yr – Wemyss Smoky Nectar 1983 Single Cask OK $375
95 Caol Ila 22 Yr Feis Ile 2019 BEST $166
89 Caol Ila 15 Yr “Unpeated Style” Bottled 2018 GOOD $130
94 Caol Ila 25 Yr BEST $200
88 Caol Ila 18 Yr BEST $100
94 Lagavulin 19 Yr Feis Ile 2019 BEST $190
87 Lagavulin 10 Yr (Travel Retail Exclusive) BEST $55
84 Lagavulin Jazz 2018 POOR $130
89 Clynelish Reserve Game of Thrones House Tyrell BEST $69
87 Caol Ila 15 Yr (2003) Refill Bourbon Unpeated N/A N/A
91 Caol Ila 12 Yr Double Matured Amoroso Cask BEST $130
89 Lagavulin 9 Yr (Cadenhead Warehouse) N/A N/A
92 Lagavulin Distillery Exclusive 2017 BEST $130
81 Templeton Rye OK $29
93 Orphan Barrel Rhetoric 22 Yr Kentucky Straight Bourbon GOOD $120
83 Blade & Bow Kentucky Straight Bourbon OK $55
87 Johnnie Walker Black Label The Director’s Cut Blade Runner 2049 GOOD $95
74 White Walker by Johnnie Walker Blended Scotch Whisky (Game of Thrones) POOR $45
79 Bulleit Bourbon POOR $30
80 Bulleit Rye OK $30
81 Talisker Storm OK $43
90 Talisker 18 Yr BEST $135
80 Talisker 10 Yr OK $50
80 Lagavulin 8 Yr OK $55
90 Mortlach 17 Yr Dimensions (Duncan Taylor) GOOD $150
85 Glenkinchie 12 Yr BEST $60
91 Talisker 30 Yr POOR $2000
86 Caol Ila 9 Yr “The Share” Western Lowland Gorilla N/A N/A
91 Glenlossie 24 Yr (Signatory Vintage) 1992 Cask No. 3457 GOOD $160
90 Linkwood 12 Yr N/A N/A
83 Glenkinchie Distiller’s Edition 2016 GOOD $70
89 Oban Distiller’s Edition 2015 Release OD 164.FA GOOD $110
90 Caol Ila Stitchell Reserve “Unpeated Style” BEST $110
87 Lagavulin Distiller’s Edition 2015 BEST $100
94 Caol Ila 27 Yr (Douglas Laing’s Old & Rare) Single Cask POOR $320
93 Talisker 25 Yr Cask Strength POOR $500
75 Dimple Pinch 12 Yr POOR $40
93 Lagavulin Feis Ile 2017 BEST $170
76 Crown Royal Blended Canadian Whiskey POOR $25
90 Lagavulin Jazz 2017 BEST $130
91 Lagavulin Feis Ile 2018 GOOD $170
90 Lagavulin 9 Yr Game of Thrones House Lannister BEST $65
86 The Singleton of Glen Ord 18 Yr GOOD $80
88 The Singleton of Glen Ord 14 Yr 5-Cask Distillery Exclusive GOOD $123
81 The Singleton of Glendullan 18 Yr POOR $80
74 The Singleton of Glendullan 12 Yr POOR $35
78 The Singleton of Glendullan 15 Yr POOR $55
92 Redemption Rye 8 Yr (Batch 2) BEST $90
84 Oban 14 Yr GOOD $70
93 Lagavulin 12 Yr 2017 Limited Edition BEST $140
90 Lagavulin 16 Yr BEST $75
81 Johnnie Walker Black Label OK $35
83 Caol Ila 12 Yr GOOD $55
87 Caol Ila 10 Yr Feis Ile 2018 POOR $180
90 Cragganmore 15 Yr (SMWS 37.106 Apple Harvest – 14 bourbon/1 red wine) BEST $130
86 Talisker Port Ruighe GOOD $83
90 Caol Ila 22-Yr (Cadenhead Small Batch) BEST $100
77 Lagavulin 5 Yr N/A N/A
91 Caol Ila 2005 (Gordon & MacPhail) 12 Yr BEST $100
88 Oban 18 Yr BEST $100