PointsNameValuePrice
85 Shady Knoll Single Barrel Rye Whiskey POOR $86
83 Shady Knoll Rye Whiskey OK $50
90 Little Rest Oloroso Sherry Hogshead – Distillery Exclusive OK $185
91 Little Rest Double Matured Cask Strength American Single Malt Whisky BEST $135
87 Little Rest American Single Malt Whisky – Port Cask GOOD $125
88 Little Rest Founders Edition American Single Malt Whisky OK $155
89 Little Rest American Single Malt Whisky – Pinot Noir Cask Batch 001 GOOD $110
86 Little Rest American Single Malt Whisky – Bourbon Cask Batch 001 OK $110
89 Little Rest American Single Malt Whisky – Batch 002 (Classic) BEST $100
89 Little Rest American Single Malt Whisky – First Edition POOR $175
86 High Plains Rye GOOD $60
84 Helderberg Winter Wheat Whiskey Batch 001 GOOD $50
87 Black Button Single Barrel # 3092 Straight Bourbon (First Fill Spirits) GOOD $68
81 Cooperstown Select American Single Malt Sherry Cask Finished OK $75
85 Rough Rider “The Big Stick” Rye Whiskey Cask Strength, Batch 32 GOOD $60
90 New York Distilling Rye 4 Yr (SMWS RW3.2 Brooklyn Apple Pie) BEST $75
88 Barrell Bourbon New Year 2022 OK $85
86 Southern Tier Bottled-In-Bond Bourbon GOOD $57
86 New York Distilling 7 Year Rye (SMWS RW3.1 Big, bold, fruity & spicy) POOR $90
89 Westland American Single Malt Whiskey Cask No 2781 GOOD $125
75 Breuckelen Single Malt 2013 (SMWS 142.1 Made in New York, New York) POOR $110
77 McKenzie Finger Lakes Rye (SMWS RW2.1 Out of the ordinary – in a very good way!) POOR $100
86 McKenzie Finger Lakes Bourbon (SMWS B6.1 Ginger-spiced sponge) POOR $90
90 Taconic Distillery Double Barrel Maple Bourbon, Release #5 BEST $60
79 Widow Jane Rye Mash Oak and Applewood-Aged Whiskey POOR $43
82 Taconic Dutchess Private Reserve Straight Bourbon Whiskey OK $38
79 Ragtime Rye POOR $45
79 Ironweed 4 Yr Malt Batch 50 N/A N/A
85 Ironweed 4 Yr Cask Strength Malt Batch 50 N/A N/A
83 Ironweed 3 Yr Cask Strength Bourbon N/A N/A
75 Iron Smoke Straight Bourbon Whiskey POOR $50
91 Hillrock Estate Solera Aged Bourbon, Sauternes Finish GOOD $100
88 Hillrock Estate Double Cask Rye Porto Finish OK $90
90 Hillrock Estate Double Cask Rye Oloroso Finish GOOD $90
89 Hillrock Estate Double Cask Rye Madeira Finish OK $90
84 Coppersea Bonticou Crag Straight Rye Malt Whisky POOR $75
83 Finger Lakes Distilling (Pursuit Series Episode 010) OK $65
85 Black Button Double Barrel Four Grain Straight Bourbon N/A N/A
86 Black Button Cask Strength Bourbon Batch 1 N/A N/A
81 Black Button Bourbon Barrel # 575 N/A N/A
85 Black Button Bourbon Barrel # 574 N/A N/A
82 Black Button Bourbon Barrel # 566 N/A N/A
87 Black Button Bourbon Barrel # 518 GOOD $68
81 Beanball Bourbon OK $33
85 Black Button American Straight Whiskey Batch 1 BEST $36
76 Four Fights Bowers Distiller’s Cut Cask Strength Single Barrel Bourbon POOR $60
85 Iron Smoke Single Barrel Straight Bourbon Whiskey – Lisa’s Liquor Barn Store Pick GOOD $60
86 McKenzie Bottled In Bond Bourbon (Wheated) BEST $42
84 Catskill Straight Rye Whiskey GOOD $43
76 Ironweed Rye Whiskey POOR $50
68 McKenzie Rye NO $42
75 McKenzie Bourbon POOR $42
73 Hudson Manhattan Rye Whiskey POOR $78
72 Hudson Baby Bourbon POOR $66
73 Cask & Crew Rye Batch #4 POOR $25
82 Catskill Most Righteous Straight Bourbon POOR $60
82 Bootlegger 21 New York Bourbon Whiskey POOR $55
79 77 Whiskey – Local Rye & Corn POOR $45
86 Hillrock Estate Single Malt OPX10 GOOD $100
90 Hillrock Estate Solera Aged Bourbon, Oloroso Finish Barrel # 106 BEST $80
84 Yankee Bourbon Batch 8 OK $60
82 Yankee Bourbon Batch 9 POOR $60
83 Yankee Rye Batch 7 OK $60
83 Black Button Small-Batch Four-Grain Straight Bourbon, Batch 5 OK $50
88 Black Button Port Finished Single Barrel Bourbon Batch 326 POOR $200