89 |
Allt-A-Bhainne 18 Yr (Gordon & MacPhail Cask # 16601402) |
POOR |
$200 |
87 |
Ailsa Bay Sweet Smoke 1.2 |
GOOD |
$110 |
86 |
Aberlour 15 Yr Distillery Exclusive |
OK |
$120 |
90 |
Aberfeldy 23 Yr Single Cask Hand Fill Vintage 2001 (Cask # 500060) |
POOR |
$286 |
92 |
Blackadder Old Man of Hoy Arcadian Raw Cask 16 Yr (Highland Park) |
GOOD |
$200 |
90 |
Kilchoman 8 Yr White Port Single Cask Cask 2015/909 |
BEST |
$130 |
85 |
Caol Ila 13 Yr Feis Ile 2024 |
POOR |
$230 |
91 |
Lagavulin 10 Yr Feis Ile 2024 |
OK |
$200 |
90 |
Laphroaig Cairdeas Cask Favourites |
BEST |
$109 |
93 |
Bowmore 19 Yr Virgin American Oak Feis Ile 2024 |
POOR |
$256 |
95 |
Bunnahabhain 23 Yr Triple Sherry Wood Finished Feis Ile 2024 |
POOR |
$500 |
95 |
Bruichladdich ROCK’NDAAL The Laddie Valinch Feis Ile 2024 |
BEST |
$139 |
89 |
Ardnahoe 5 Yr Inaugural Release |
BEST |
$95 |
92 |
Glenallachie 18 Yr Hand Fill (Cask # 5732) |
OK |
$220 |
90 |
Dailuaine 13 Yr (Dram Mor) |
BEST |
$100 |
87 |
Balblair Hand Bottling (Cask # 487) for Highland Whisky Festival 2023 |
POOR |
$200 |
89 |
Cardhu 11 Yr Hand Fill Distillery Exclusive |
OK |
$145 |
86 |
New Riff 8 Yr Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
OK |
$68 |
89 |
Bardstown – Fercullen Blended Whiskey Collaborative Series |
POOR |
$200 |
85 |
Lost Lantern Shadow Blended American Malt Whiskey (Edition 2023 SHD-1) |
OK |
$93 |
86 |
Lost Lantern Flame American Blended Malt Whiskey |
OK |
$93 |
87 |
St George Mountain Meadow Single Malt 4 Yr (Lost Lantern Edition 2023 STG-1) |
OK |
$140 |
85 |
Cedar Ridge Iowa Straight Wheat Whiskey 6 Yr (Lost Lantern 2024 Single Cask # 6) |
GOOD |
$86 |
91 |
Tom’s Foolery Ohio Straight Rye 9 Yr (Lost Lantern 2024 Single Cask # 4) |
OK |
$116 |
86 |
FEW Spirits Illinois 5 Yr Straight Bourbon Whiskey (Lost Lantern 2024 Single Cask # 3) |
POOR |
$86 |
89 |
Starlight Single Cask Straight Bourbon 6 Yr (Lost Lantern 2024 Single Cask # 1) |
OK |
$86 |
89 |
Lost Lantern Far Flung Rye |
OK |
$100 |
94 |
Oktomore Farm 10 Yr Islay Single Malt Private Cask Bottling (Cask # 3078) |
POOR |
$450 |
93 |
Glenallachie 13 Yr Madeira Wood Finish |
BEST |
$150 |
92 |
Octomore 14.1 |
OK |
$220 |
89 |
Octomore 14.2 |
POOR |
$250 |
93 |
Octomore 13.3 |
POOR |
$284 |
91 |
Octomore 13.1 |
POOR |
$215 |
95 |
Octomore 13.2 |
GOOD |
$230 |
93 |
Chichibu Single Malt Red Wine Cask 2023 |
POOR |
$300 |
87 |
Port Askaig Gateway to Islay Cask Strength Small Batch (#01-2023) |
BEST |
$86 |
87 |
Glenburgie-Glenlivet 12 Year (Cadenhead’s) |
BEST |
$76 |
86 |
Dailuaine-Glenlivet 10 Year (Cadenhead Small Batch) |
OK |
$126 |
86 |
Blackadder The Legendary 10 Year |
OK |
$113 |
87 |
Auchroisk 12 Year (Old Particular) |
BEST |
$98 |
91 |
Benriach 14 Year Distillery Exclusive Pedro Ximenez Puncheon |
GOOD |
$164 |
87 |
Glenmorangie A Tale of Tokyo Limited Edition Single Malt Scotch |
BEST |
$100 |
86 |
New Riff Sour Mash Single Malt Cask Strength Whiskey |
GOOD |
$95 |
80 |
Spirits of French Lick Hindostan Falls Botted-In-Bond Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$60 |
90 |
Lagg Single Malt Scotch Whisky – Corriecravie Edition – Sherry Cask Finish |
BEST |
$70 |
90 |
NULU Double Oaked Bourbon, Barrel B1003 (Westport) |
GOOD |
$87 |
84 |
Tamnavulin 11 Yr Single Malt Scotch (Distiller’s Art) |
POOR |
$116 |
89 |
Weetwood “The Cheshire” Single Malt English Whisky |
BEST |
$75 |
78 |
Silkie ‘The Legendary” Irish Whiskey Finished in Spanish Red Wine Casks |
POOR |
$53 |
89 |
O.K.I. Reserve Blended Bourbon Whiskey Batch 1 |
GOOD |
$80 |
87 |
Russell’s Reserve Private Barrel Selection (Westport) |
GOOD |
$80 |
86 |
Bunnahabhain 12 Year Cask Strength 2023 Edition |
GOOD |
$100 |
81 |
West Cork Irish Whiskey Cask Strength |
OK |
$48 |
87 |
Boone County Founder’s Reserve Bourbon Finished in Amburana Casks |
GOOD |
$70 |
87 |
Wire Works Single Malt English Whisky Alter Ego |
BEST |
$80 |
86 |
Clydeside Lowland Single Malt Scotch Whisky – 2023 Limited Edition |
GOOD |
$80 |
85 |
Ry3 Rye Whiskey Finished in Madeira Casks (Party Source – Batch PR#006) |
POOR |
$88 |
76 |
Copper & Kings Bourbon Finished in Apple Brandy Barrels |
POOR |
$65 |
86 |
Del Bac Dorado American Single Malt Whiskey |
BEST |
$65 |
84 |
Two Stacks Double Barrel Single Malt Irish Whiskey |
GOOD |
$50 |
89 |
Cedar Ridge Barrel Proof Small Batch Bourbon (Batch 0003) |
BEST |
$50 |
90 |
Found North Single Barrel Canadian Rye Whisky Season 001, Barrel 002 (Gordon’s Store Pick) |
GOOD |
$100 |
89 |
Kingsbarns Bell Rock Cask Strength Single Malt Scotch Whisky |
BEST |
$76 |
87 |
Castle & Key Restoration Rye Single Barrel (Gordon’s Store Pick) |
BEST |
$65 |
85 |
Kamet Single Malt Whisky |
BEST |
$60 |
92 |
Blackadder Raw Cask Peat Reek 10 Yr Single Malt Scotch Recharred Cask Finish (Cask #PR 2022-01) |
BEST |
$170 |
86 |
Lady of the Glen 13 Yr (Dufftown, Cask #705315) |
POOR |
$186 |
88 |
Old Line American Single Malt (Saratoga Whiskey Club) |
BEST |
$60 |
90 |
MARS Shinshu Komagatake 2023 Edition |
BEST |
$130 |
88 |
Campbeltown Loch Blended Malt |
BEST |
$65 |
91 |
Glen Scotia 8 Yr Distillery Exclusive First-Fill Oloroso Hogshead (Cask # 21/655-1) |
BEST |
$102 |
89 |
Oban 11 Yr Hand-Filled Distillery Exclusive, Batch # 3, Bourbon Barrel |
OK |
$150 |
90 |
Glenkinchie 12 Yr Hand Fill Re-Charred Red Wine Cask, Batch 002 |
GOOD |
$157 |
88 |
Girvan 14 Yr Single Grain (Single Cask Nation, Cask #549525) |
GOOD |
$107 |
86 |
Claxton’s Grain Barn 30 Yr |
POOR |
$160 |
91 |
Adelphi’s Breath of the Isles 16 Yr Single Cask Single Malt Scotch |
GOOD |
$136 |
89 |
Ardnamurchan AD / The ArdnAmerica Tour Bottling |
BEST |
$96 |
90 |
Clynelish 15 Yr (Gordon & MacPhail Connoissseur’s Choice) |
GOOD |
$150 |
90 |
Balblair 16 Yr – Hand Bottling Cask # 422 |
GOOD |
$160 |
93 |
Highland Park 13 Yr Distillery Exclusive Single Cask |
GOOD |
$200 |
85 |
Blackadder Raw Cask Macduff 14 Yr Dram Hunter |
POOR |
$167 |
86 |
Blackadder Raw Cask Inchgower 2009 12 Yr |
POOR |
$136 |
92 |
Blackadder Raw Cask Balblair 10 Yr – Oloroso Cask (Cask # 3231) |
BEST |
$155 |
90 |
Clynelish Hand-Fill Distillery Exclusive, Batch 2023/006, Ex Bourbon |
GOOD |
$140 |
91 |
Penderyn Single Malt Welsh Whisky Ex-Malvasia Madeira Wine Cask (The ImpEx Collection Cask # 138/2017) |
BEST |
$120 |
87 |
Da Mhile Organic Single Malt Welsh Whisky 2022 Limited Edition Single Cask # MM1607 |
GOOD |
$130 |
85 |
Carpathian Romanian Single Malt Whisky – Oloroso Sherry Cask Finished (Cask # 3450) |
BEST |
$60 |
90 |
Carpathian Romanian Single Malt Whisky – Tawny Port Finish (Cask # 3200) |
BEST |
$60 |
86 |
Carpathian Romanian Single Malt Whisky – Romanian Pinot Noir Matured (Cask # 2895) |
BEST |
$60 |
89 |
Carpathian Romanian Single Malt Whisky – Romanian Feteasca Negara Wine Cask (Cask # 3800) |
BEST |
$60 |
91 |
Bunnahabhain 6 Yr (SMWS 10.193 Simply Peat) |
BEST |
$125 |
92 |
Bunnahabhain 6 Yr (SMWS 10.197 A Slow Sipper) |
BEST |
$125 |
90 |
Bunnahabhain 14 Year (SMWS 10.249 Spectacular horse’s mane waves 30th Anniversary Release) |
OK |
$190 |
89 |
Bunnahabhain 14 Year ( SMWS 10.184 Brittle Royale) |
OK |
$145 |
87 |
Bunnahabhain Cruach-Mhona Travel Exclusive |
BEST |
$80 |
86 |
Bunnahabhain Eirigh Na Greine Travel Exclusive |
BEST |
$75 |
88 |
Bunnahabhain Feis Ile 2022 Abhainn Araig |
OK |
$140 |
85 |
Bunnahabhain An Cladach Travel Exclusive |
BEST |
$65 |
89 |
Little Rest American Single Malt Whisky – First Edition |
POOR |
$175 |
84 |
Kinsey 4 Yr American Whiskey |
GOOD |
$40 |
89 |
Kanosuke Single Malt Japanese Whisky 2022 |
POOR |
$180 |
88 |
Kanosuke Single Malt Japanese Whisky 2021 First Edition |
POOR |
$250 |
91 |
Eigashima Kuri (Chestnut) Cask, Cask # 118171 |
GOOD |
$150 |
87 |
Akashi Eigashima Sextet Single Malt Japanese Whisky |
GOOD |
$105 |
87 |
Nikka Yoichi Grande Single Malt Whisky |
BEST |
$80 |
95 |
Hakushu 24 Yr 1981 |
N/A |
N/A |
90 |
Nagahama Single Malt Japanese Whisky – The First Batch |
OK |
$175 |
81 |
Clydeside Stobcross Lowland Single Malt Scotch Whisky |
OK |
$60 |
84 |
Starward Solera Single Malt Whisky |
GOOD |
$66 |
86 |
West Cork Glengarriff Bog Oak Charred Cask Single Malt Irish Whiskey |
BEST |
$41 |
90 |
NULU Single Barrel 8 Yr Bourbon (Barrel # 1) |
OK |
$110 |
82 |
King’s Family Distillery American Whiskey Finished in Islay Casks |
POOR |
$70 |
90 |
King’s Family Distillery Ryeconic Rye Whiskey |
BEST |
$60 |
88 |
King’s Family Distillery 6 Yr Straight Rye |
GOOD |
$69 |
90 |
King’s Family Distillery Tennessee Standard Bourbon |
BEST |
$70 |
89 |
King’s Family Distillery Wheated 5 Year Bourbon |
GOOD |
$70 |
79 |
Barrell American Vatted Malt Whiskey |
POOR |
$80 |
90 |
Barrell Craft Spirits Gray Label Bourbon, 5th Release |
POOR |
$250 |
88 |
Barrell Vantage Bourbon |
GOOD |
$80 |
87 |
Barrell Seagrass Rye Whiskey |
GOOD |
$80 |
89 |
Barrell Craft Spirits Gray Label Seagrass 16 Year Limited Edition |
POOR |
$230 |
87 |
Barrell Bourbon New Year 2023 |
OK |
$85 |
88 |
Barrell Craft Spirits 24 Yr Gray Label Whiskey |
POOR |
$250 |
93 |
Found North Whisky Single Barrel Rye – New Charred Oak Finish |
N/A |
N/A |
90 |
Found North Whisky Single Barrel Rye – Sherry Cask Finish |
N/A |
N/A |
90 |
Found North Whisky Batch 006 |
GOOD |
$150 |
93 |
Found North Whisky Batch 005 |
BEST |
$125 |
93 |
Found North Whisky Batch 004 |
BEST |
$145 |
90 |
Found North Whisky Batch 003 |
OK |
$135 |
94 |
Found North Whisky Batch 002 |
BEST |
$125 |
90 |
Found North Whisky Batch 001 |
OK |
$115 |
88 |
Boone County 5 Yr Single Barrel Pot Still Bourbon: Barrel BCP1 |
GOOD |
$70 |
89 |
Bunnahabhain 16 Yr Moine (Blackadder Raw Cask) |
POOR |
$225 |
84 |
Ardnamurchan 5 Yr (SMWS 149.2 Peaty peninsula) |
POOR |
$135 |
87 |
Caol Ila 10 Yr (SMWS 53.375 Clambake on the beach) |
GOOD |
$135 |
86 |
Tobermory 15 Yr (SMWS 42.68) |
POOR |
$170 |
90 |
Blair Athol 14 Yr (SMWS 68.93 Supper in the dunnage) |
GOOD |
$160 |
89 |
Glendronach 11 Yr (SMWS 96.34 Stroll through the seasons) |
GOOD |
$120 |
88 |
Glenfarclas 7 Yr (SMWS 1.238 Well Danced-Upon Oak) |
GOOD |
$115 |
86 |
Smokehead Rum Rebel Islay Single Malt Scotch Whisky |
GOOD |
$87 |
88 |
Murray McDavid Peatside 6 Yr Blended Malt – “The Vatting” – Distilled 2010 |
BEST |
$90 |
84 |
Indri Single Malt Indian Whisky |
GOOD |
$55 |
82 |
Smoke Wagon Malted Straight Rye Whiskey |
POOR |
$80 |
86 |
Blanton’s Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon (Bayway) |
OK |
$75 |
88 |
Filey Bay Flagship Yorkshire Single Malt Whisky |
BEST |
$68 |
84 |
Elijah Craig Barrel Proof – Private Barrel # 6634306 (Bayway World of Liquor) |
OK |
$65 |
91 |
Caol Ila 14 Yr Single Malt Scotch (Rare Find, Cask 317325) |
BEST |
$125 |
85 |
Wellwood Gardens Wheated Bourbon |
GOOD |
$50 |
84 |
Down Home Straight Rye Finished in Toasted White Oak Barrels |
POOR |
$73 |
86 |
Old Scout Single Barrel Bourbon – Barrel 24478 (Party Source) |
OK |
$70 |
89 |
New Riff Single Barrel Rye – (Westport Whiskey & Wine) |
GOOD |
$75 |
84 |
Nc’Nean Organic Single Malt Scotch Whisky |
GOOD |
$75 |
82 |
Teeling Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey – Wonders of Wood, First Edition |
POOR |
$100 |
86 |
Amrut Single Cask Single Grain Indian Whisky |
GOOD |
$80 |
87 |
Wolfburn 7 Year Cask Strength Single Malt Scotch (Father’s Day Limited Release) |
BEST |
$95 |
86 |
Benrinnes 11 Year Single Malt Scotch (Auld Goonsy’s Malt) |
GOOD |
$95 |
85 |
Peerless Single Barrel Rye (Westport Whiskey & Wine, Barrel # R170103106) |
POOR |
$85 |
82 |
Balcones Texas Single Malt Whiskey Single Barrel (Total Wine) |
OK |
$65 |
86 |
Nelson Bros. Reserve Bourbon Whiskey |
GOOD |
$60 |
84 |
Lindores Lowland Single Malt Scotch Whisky |
GOOD |
$70 |
86 |
Eifel German Single Malt Whisky Edition 2021 |
BEST |
$71 |
86 |
High Plains Rye |
GOOD |
$60 |
84 |
Connacht Single Malt Irish Whiskey Batch 1 |
GOOD |
$65 |
81 |
Barrell Craft Spirits Single Barrel Bourbon (Barrel 23A5 – Westport Whiskey & Wine) |
POOR |
$95 |
89 |
Stranahan’s Colorado Whiskey, Barrel 12-0819 (Total Wine) |
BEST |
$75 |
83 |
Lochlea Our Barley Single Malt Scotch Whisky |
GOOD |
$70 |
88 |
Starlight Carl T Huber’s Single Barrel Bourbon Finished in Cognac Barrels |
GOOD |
$75 |
74 |
291 Colorado Bourbon Whiskey Barrel Proof Single Barrel – Aspen Wood Stave Finish |
POOR |
$110 |
90 |
Blackwood Toasted Bourbon, Batch 1 |
POOR |
$150 |
87 |
Copper & Kings Apple Brandy Finished Bourbon: 7 Yr Hand Fill |
BEST |
$65 |
93 |
NULU Double Oaked Bourbon (Party Source) |
BEST |
$100 |
85 |
Heaven’s Door Decades 10 Yr Bourbon |
POOR |
$120 |
91 |
Blood Oath Pact No. 8 |
POOR |
$150 |
88 |
Blue Note Juke Joint Uncut Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
BEST |
$40 |
90 |
King’s Family Distillery Bourbon Whiskey Finished in a Honey Barrel |
BEST |
$65 |
89 |
Doc Swinson’s Alter Ego Solera Method Straight Rye Whiskey |
BEST |
$50 |
92 |
Proof And Wood 21 Year ‘Good Day’ Blended Canadian Whiskey |
BEST |
$100 |
86 |
Del Bac The 9th Floor American Single Malt Private Barrel |
BEST |
$71 |
91 |
Highland Park 13 Yr (SMWS 4.283 Selkies, Kelpies and Peat Reek) |
GOOD |
$145 |
91 |
Benrinnes 10 Yr (SMWS 36 Rare Release -A Reward For Patience) |
BEST |
$115 |
86 |
Copperworks 3 Yr Single Malt (SMWS 143.1 Sea Buckthorn Tea Time) |
GOOD |
$95 |
90 |
Wattie Boone & Sons 9 Year Small Batch American Whiskey |
GOOD |
$100 |
90 |
Peerless Single Barrel Bourbon “Lemon and Licorice” – Distillery Exclusive |
GOOD |
$100 |
93 |
Glenturret 20 Yr (SMWS 16.59 Too Good To Be True) |
OK |
$225 |
92 |
Glenturret 20 Yr (SMWS 16.58 Hair-Tingling Revelation) |
OK |
$225 |
90 |
Glenturret 15 Yr 2021 Edition |
BEST |
$130 |
87 |
Glenturret 12 Yr 2021 Edition |
BEST |
$76 |
86 |
Glenturret Triple Wood 2021 Edition |
BEST |
$55 |
85 |
Glenturret 10 Yr Peat Smoked 2021 Edition |
BEST |
$65 |
83 |
Blair Athol 12 Yr First Edition (DS Tayman) |
OK |
$77 |
87 |
Backwoods Distilling Australian Rye 3 Yr (Single Cask Nation, Cask # 14) |
POOR |
$110 |
86 |
Laphroaig 10 Yr (SMWS 29.281 Driftwood barbecue) |
POOR |
$160 |
89 |
Caol Ila 8 Yr (SMWS Distillery 53 Rare Release – Throw The Cork Away!) |
GOOD |
$135 |
87 |
Bowmore 17 Yr (SMWS Distillery 3 Rare Release – Time Travelers) |
POOR |
$270 |
91 |
Bowmore 17 Yr (SMWS 3.324 Split Personality) |
POOR |
$225 |
89 |
Bunnahabhain Fèis Ìle 2022: 2004 Mòine Tokaji Cask Finish |
POOR |
$244 |
89 |
Kilchoman Madeira Cask Matured |
BEST |
$100 |
90 |
J Mattingly 1845 Single Barrel Light Whiskey (Party Source) |
BEST |
$120 |
89 |
Balcones Single Barrel Single Malt (Total Wine Store Pick) |
BEST |
$80 |
87 |
Balcones 4 Yr Single Malt (SMWS 140.4 Throws you curve balls) |
BEST |
$95 |
83 |
Old Pepper Single Malt Single Barrel – Distillery exclusive |
OK |
$100 |
92 |
Proof and Wood ‘Seasons 2021’ American Blended Whiskey |
OK |
$197 |
88 |
Proof and Wood Vertigo 2021 |
OK |
$140 |
87 |
Two Stacks Irish Whiskey – Smoke & Mirrors Peated Stout Cask Single Malt |
BEST |
$70 |
86 |
Two Stacks Irish Whiskey – Time Well Spent 12 Yr Rye Cask Finish Single Grain |
POOR |
$200 |
90 |
Two Stacks Irish Whiskey – Tawny Port Cask Finish |
BEST |
$85 |
86 |
Two Stacks Irish Whiskey – Sauternes Cask Finish |
GOOD |
$85 |
89 |
Two Stacks Irish Whiskey – Apricot Brandy Cask Finish |
BEST |
$85 |
88 |
Two Stacks Irish Whiskey – Barbados Rum Cask Finish |
BEST |
$85 |
93 |
Macallan 12 Yr (SMWS 24.151 Meandering a maze of souks) |
GOOD |
$175 |
93 |
Macallan 12 Yr (SMWS 24.149 Character and Grace) |
GOOD |
$175 |
82 |
Macallan 12 Yr (SMWS 24.152 Albino Rhino) |
POOR |
$175 |
92 |
Glenrothes 23 Yr (SMWS 30.116 A Christmas Changeling) |
POOR |
$260 |
85 |
Glenrothes 21 Yr (Small Batch Whisky Collection) |
POOR |
$220 |
87 |
Glenrothes 19 Yr – “Italian Bakery Delight” (Wemyss Malts) |
GOOD |
$126 |
91 |
Highland Park Cask Strength, Release #2 |
BEST |
$96 |
85 |
Teeling Brabazon Volume IV (Four) 13 Yr Single Malt |
OK |
$112 |
91 |
Fercullen 20 Yr 5 Elements Single Malt Irish Whiskey |
POOR |
$257 |
88 |
Teeling 13 Yr Single Grain |
GOOD |
$100 |
85 |
Teeling Renaissance 18 Yr, Series 4 |
POOR |
$165 |
86 |
Writers Tears 2021 Cask Strength Limited Edition |
POOR |
$155 |
89 |
Dingle Single Malt Batch 6 |
BEST |
$85 |
83 |
Kirker & Greer Single Grain 10 Yr |
GOOD |
$50 |
88 |
M & H Apex Pomegranate Wine Cask Single Malt Whisky |
BEST |
$93 |
86 |
M & H Apex Fortified Red Wine Cask Single Malt Whisky |
GOOD |
$93 |
86 |
M & H Apex Dead Sea Single Malt Whisky |
OK |
$120 |
86 |
M&H Elements Single Malt Whisky – Peated Cask |
BEST |
$66 |
83 |
M & H Elements Single Malt Whisky – Red Wine |
GOOD |
$60 |
82 |
M & H Elements Single Malt Whisky – Sherry |
POOR |
$80 |
85 |
M & H Classic Single Malt Whisky |
BEST |
$65 |
82 |
Laws San Luis Valley Straight Rye Cask |
POOR |
$86 |
91 |
Barrell Craft Spirits Seagrass 16 Yr Rye |
POOR |
$230 |
84 |
Woodinville Cask Strength Straight Rye Whiskey |
POOR |
$70 |
90 |
New York Distilling Rye 4 Yr (SMWS RW3.2 Brooklyn Apple Pie) |
BEST |
$75 |
87 |
George Dickel Leopold Bros Collaboration Rye Blend |
POOR |
$110 |
89 |
New Riff Malted Rye 6 Yr |
GOOD |
$70 |
92 |
Blackadder Peat Reek Islay 10 Yr |
BEST |
$160 |
89 |
Blackadder Sherry Snake – First Edition, October 2020 |
GOOD |
$110 |
93 |
Amrut Aatma Single Cask Indian Single Malt – Fino Cask |
GOOD |
$200 |
90 |
Murray McDavid “Mystery Malt” Safe Haven 6 Yr 2014 |
BEST |
$69 |
88 |
Dailuaine 12 Yr Benchmark 2009 (Murray McDavid) |
GOOD |
$110 |
89 |
Waterford The Cuvee Irish Single Malt |
BEST |
$93 |
80 |
Waterford Biodynamic Luna 1.1 Irish Single Malt |
POOR |
$113 |
84 |
Omar Single Malt Whisky |
GOOD |
$56 |
88 |
Sagamore Spirit 8 Yr Rye Reserve Series |
GOOD |
$80 |
86 |
Breckenridge Bourbon High Proof |
GOOD |
$53 |
85 |
Cadenhead’s Craigellachie 12 Yr – Original Collection |
GOOD |
$100 |
77 |
Blackadder Puff Adder Whisky |
POOR |
$99 |
86 |
Fukano Japanese Rice Whisky Edition 2021 |
GOOD |
$85 |
90 |
Clynelish 8 Yr (SMWS 26.168 A rustling through the dunes) |
BEST |
$115 |
91 |
Clynelish 10 Yr (SMWS 26.165 Surprising, inspiring, indulging!) |
BEST |
$135 |
89 |
Single Cask Nation Inchfad 15 Yr |
OK |
$150 |
91 |
Glen Ord 28 Yr (SMWS 77.65 Pure Dead Brilliant) |
POOR |
$475 |
84 |
Murray McDavid North British 13 Yr Single Grain |
OK |
$80 |
90 |
Clynelish 19 Yr (Wemyss Malts) |
GOOD |
$150 |
86 |
Woodinville Bourbon finished in Port Casks (Distillery Exclusive) |
GOOD |
$50 |
86 |
MARS Iwai Tradition Japanese Blend Napa Wine Cask Finish |
GOOD |
$70 |
85 |
Ardmore 10 Yr (James Eadie) |
BEST |
$75 |
89 |
Murray McDavid Righ Seumas II 12YR Crafted Blend |
BEST |
$79 |
93 |
1792 Full Proof Bourbon (Bayway Store Pick) |
BEST |
$65 |
87 |
Tipperary Irish Single Malt Whiskey – Batch 1 |
BEST |
$86 |
88 |
Eifel German Peated Rye Whisky Edition 2021 |
OK |
$82 |
74 |
Old Pepper Finest Kentucky Oak Straight Rye – Distillery Exclusive |
POOR |
$80 |
86 |
Milk & Honey APEX Single Malt Whisky – Cognac Finish |
GOOD |
$93 |
85 |
Cardinal Spirits Bourbon Barrel Proof (Party Source Store Pick) |
GOOD |
$52 |
86 |
Linkwood 12 Yr Single Malt (DS Tayman) |
GOOD |
$76 |
78 |
Samuel Gelston’s 12 Year Single Malt Irish Whiskey – Sherry Cask |
POOR |
$70 |
82 |
Fuji Single Grain Japanese Whiskey |
POOR |
$100 |
88 |
Barrell Craft Spirits 14 Year Single-Barrel Canadian Rye (Bottle #49, Barrel V207) |
POOR |
$249 |
85 |
Boone County Pot Still Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
GOOD |
$50 |
86 |
Cotswolds Sherry Cask Single Malt Whisky |
GOOD |
$89 |
88 |
Two Stacks Irish Whiskey Cask Strength |
BEST |
$60 |
88 |
Bunnahabhain 7 Yr Single Malt (Cadenhead Original Collection) |
BEST |
$76 |
85 |
Castle & Key Restoration Rye Batch 3 |
GOOD |
$46 |
81 |
Ohishi Whisky Ex-Brandy Cask |
POOR |
$70 |
84 |
The Wiseman Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
OK |
$65 |
87 |
Jeptha Creed Hand-Filled Bourbon |
OK |
$100 |
83 |
Three Boys Hand-Filled Bourbon |
POOR |
$155 |
88 |
Barrell Bourbon New Year 2022 |
OK |
$85 |
86 |
Bardstown Bourbon Company Triple Blended Stave Finish |
POOR |
$200 |
86 |
Peerless Double Oak Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$135 |
85 |
Daviess County Limited Edition Double Barrel Bourbon |
GOOD |
$60 |
82 |
American Highway Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$100 |
86 |
Ragged Branch Double Oaked Signature Bourbon Virginia Straight Bourbon Whiskey (Barrel # 1905) |
GOOD |
$50 |
83 |
Teerenpeli Porti Single Malt Whisky |
POOR |
$110 |
89 |
Lost Distilleries Lossit Classic Selection |
BEST |
$36 |
87 |
Lost Distilleries Gerston Archivist Selection |
BEST |
$50 |
87 |
Lost Distilleries Benachie (Jericho) Classic Selection |
BEST |
$36 |
78 |
Lost Distilleries Auchnagie Archivist Selection |
POOR |
$50 |
86 |
Lost Distilleries Towiemore Classic Selection |
BEST |
$36 |
85 |
Lost Distilleries Stratheden Archivist Selection |
BEST |
$50 |
91 |
Starward Single Barrel Single Malt Australian Whisky – Barrel # 10333 (Saratoga Whskey Club) |
BEST |
$70 |
92 |
Bowmore 16 Yr (SMWS 3.316 Madame Butterfly in the Garden of Eden) |
POOR |
$260 |
88 |
Ardbeg Scorch |
OK |
$150 |
90 |
Bunnahabhain 6 Yr (SMWS 10.190 Make Moine a Devil) |
BEST |
$120 |
91 |
Caol Ila 10 Yr (SMWS 53.367 A Green Sea Tapestry) |
GOOD |
$145 |
87 |
Port Charlotte PAC: 01 2011 |
OK |
$140 |
87 |
Stauning Bastard Danish Whisky |
OK |
$90 |
90 |
Stauning El Clasico |
GOOD |
$90 |
89 |
Stauning Smoke – Single Malt Whisky |
BEST |
$95 |
87 |
Stauning KAOS Triple Malt Whisky |
BEST |
$85 |
85 |
Stauning Rye Whisky |
OK |
$76 |
91 |
The First Tsunuki Single Malt Japanese Whisky |
POOR |
$250 |
87 |
Komagatake Single Malt Japanese Whisky Tsunuki Aging 2020 |
POOR |
$190 |
91 |
Komagatake Yakushima Aging 2020 |
POOR |
$250 |
86 |
Komagatake Limited Edition 2020 Single Malt Japanese Whisky |
POOR |
$160 |
88 |
Mars Maltage “Cosmo” Wine Cask Finish 2020 Japanese Whisky |
GOOD |
$120 |
86 |
Iwai Tradition Wine Cask Finish |
GOOD |
$65 |
87 |
Three Boys Farm Distillery Hand-Filled Rye |
POOR |
$157 |
87 |
Very Olde St Nick Cask Strength Rye Whiskey – Summer Rye |
POOR |
$169 |
88 |
Boone County Single Barrel Rye |
GOOD |
$69 |
86 |
Peerless Single Barrel Rye – “Apple Pie” (Justin’s House of Bourbon) |
POOR |
$95 |
86 |
Old Pepper Single Barrel Rye – Batch K06 |
OK |
$80 |
85 |
NULU Rye Single Barrel Toasted Barrel Finish (Total Wine) |
OK |
$72 |
88 |
Nashville Barrel Company Single Barrel (Total Wine) |
POOR |
$115 |
85 |
The Senator Barrel Proof Rye |
OK |
$80 |
79 |
Balcones True Blue Corn Whiskey – Cask Strength – Single Barrel (SF Wine Trading Co) |
POOR |
$60 |
87 |
Old Line American Single Malt Whiskey – Cask Strength |
BEST |
$55 |
86 |
Starlight Carl T Huber’s Single Barrel Bourbon 4 Yr (Total Wine) |
GOOD |
$50 |
85 |
George A. Dickel 15-Yr Single Barrel Bourbon |
GOOD |
$60 |
88 |
Glen Scotia 10 Yr Single Cask (SMWS 93.151 Members remember embers) |
GOOD |
$130 |
85 |
Penderyn 7 Yr Single Cask First-Fill Ruby Port Barrique (SMWS 128.12 Where dwell the brave at heart) |
POOR |
$155 |
91 |
Bushmills 17 Yr Irish Malt Whiskey (SMWS 51.19 As Fresh As A Mountain Stream) |
POOR |
$245 |
86 |
Rock Town Arkansas Bourbon 5 Yr (SMWS B3.8 Breakfast of Champions) |
OK |
$80 |
81 |
Westland Distillery & Lucky Envelope Brewing Cask Exchange American Single Malt Whiskey |
POOR |
$123 |
86 |
Woodinville Rye Cask Strength |
OK |
$70 |
88 |
Backbone Single Barrel Straight Bourbon Whiskey – Rum Finish (Prav Saraff) |
GOOD |
$70 |
88 |
Angel’s Envy Port Finished Bourbon – Single Barrel Private Selection (Party Source – Barrel 4150) |
OK |
$104 |
83 |
Old Scout Straight Bourbon Whiskey 5 Yr Single Barrel Select (Bourbon Outfitter) |
OK |
$55 |
87 |
Old Scout Straight Bourbon Whiskey 5 Yr Single Barrel Select (Potomac Wines & Spirits) |
BEST |
$50 |
81 |
Starlight Carl T. Huber’s Double Oaked Bourbon – Barrel DB003 (Prav Saraff) |
POOR |
$100 |
85 |
NULU Toasted Straight Bourbon – Single Barrel Select for Party Source (Barrel B31T) |
POOR |
$145 |
88 |
New Riff Single Barrel Bourbon – Justin’s House of Bourbon (Barrel # 16-3293) |
BEST |
$50 |
83 |
New Riff Single Barrel Bourbon – Westport Whiskey & Wine Barrel Pick (Barrel # 16-2003) |
OK |
$50 |
87 |
Three Boys Farm Distillery Hand Filled 7 Yr Bourbon |
POOR |
$145 |
86 |
Barrel House Rock Castle Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Barrel Proof (Batch 11) |
POOR |
$85 |
87 |
Boone County 8 Yr Single Barrel Wheated Bourbon (Barrel BCW43) |
OK |
$99 |
90 |
Boone County 7 Yr Single Barrel Wheated Bourbon (Barrel BCW42) |
GOOD |
$85 |
84 |
Neely Family Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon (Barrel # 80) |
POOR |
$80 |
87 |
Yellowstone Kentucky Straight Bourbon – Hand Picked Collection – Single Barrel (Total Wine) |
GOOD |
$75 |
83 |
Bluegrass Distillers Kentucky Straight Bourbon – Wheated Single Barrel |
OK |
$50 |
87 |
Clynelish 20 Yr (Gordon & McPhail- Connoisseurs Choice) |
POOR |
$230 |
85 |
Blair Athol 20 Yr (Distiller’s Art) |
POOR |
$140 |
85 |
Blair Athol 11 Yr (SMWS 68.47 Riveting) |
OK |
$120 |
82 |
Torabhaig 2017 Legacy Series – The Inaugural Release |
OK |
$75 |
90 |
Old Pulteney 13 Yr (SMWS 52.36 Shades of black) |
GOOD |
$140 |
88 |
Old Pulteney 26 Yr (SMWS 52.34 Decidedly Delectatious) |
POOR |
$385 |
88 |
Clynelish 9 Yr (SMWS 26.158 Waxing tropical) |
GOOD |
$120 |
87 |
Auchroisk 8 Yr (SMWS 95.46 Earthy and Mysterious) |
BEST |
$100 |
81 |
Glenallachie 12 Yr Single Cask Whisky Ruby Port Pipe Batch 3 (Cask #1867) |
POOR |
$120 |
91 |
Craigellachie 21 Yr (Distiller’s Art) |
GOOD |
$160 |
84 |
Craigellachie 12 Yr (Heroes & Heretics – The Disciples: 1st Edition – Cask 900777) |
OK |
$100 |
95 |
Macallan 12 Yr (SMWS 24.147 The deepest of mahogany) |
BEST |
$155 |
89 |
Cragganmore 18 Yr (SMWS 37.132 Irresistibly tropical) |
POOR |
$190 |
86 |
Glen Grant 17 Yr (SMWS 9.191 Granny’s kitchen on baking day) |
POOR |
$175 |
87 |
Glentauchers 18 Yr (SMWS 63.72 Commands your attention) |
POOR |
$175 |
90 |
Port Charlotte OLC: 01 2010 |
BEST |
$125 |
91 |
Bowmore 16 Yr (SMWS 3.315 A moment of salinity) |
OK |
$175 |
90 |
Bowmore 20 Yr (Old Particular) |
OK |
$174 |
83 |
Caol Ila 11 Yr (SMWS 53.349 Assertively Coastal) |
POOR |
$140 |
85 |
Caol Ila 11 Yr 2005 (Gordon & MacPhail) |
OK |
$112 |
89 |
Signatory Vintage Cask Strength Collection – Bunnahabhain 2008 12 Yr First-Fill Sherry (Norfolk Wine & Spirits) |
OK |
$150 |
86 |
Bunnahabhain 7 Yr – Octave “STEELHEART” (Duncan Taylor Cask # 389728) |
GOOD |
$80 |
83 |
Sagamore Spirit Distiller’s Select Tequila Finish Rye Whiskey |
OK |
$58 |
87 |
Sagamore Spirit Distiller’s Select Manhattan Finished Rye Whiskey |
GOOD |
$69 |
84 |
Sagamore Spirit Cask Strength Straight Rye Whiskey |
OK |
$63 |
86 |
Sagamore Spirit Double Oak Straight Rye Whiskey |
GOOD |
$52 |
89 |
Starward Single Cask Single Malt Australian Whisky (Women Who Whiskey – Chicago) |
BEST |
$70 |
89 |
Starward Single Cask Single Malt Australian Whisky (Wally’s Santa Monica) |
BEST |
$70 |
90 |
Starward Single Cask Single Malt Australian Whisky (Park Avenue Liquor) |
BEST |
$75 |
87 |
Starward Solera Australian Single Malt Whisky |
BEST |
$70 |
86 |
Starward Two Fold Australian Whisky |
BEST |
$35 |
86 |
Starward Nova Australian Whisky |
BEST |
$55 |
90 |
Blue Spot Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey |
BEST |
$70 |
88 |
Teeling Blackpitts |
BEST |
$80 |
91 |
Teeling Renaissance Series 2 18 Yr |
OK |
$180 |
90 |
Tomatin 2002 16 Yr (Gordon & MacPhail Connoisseurs Choice) |
GOOD |
$145 |
88 |
Tomatin 31 Yr (SMWS 11.41 Smoke, mirrors & honey traps) |
POOR |
$585 |
91 |
Tomatin 30 Yr Batch 1 |
POOR |
$400 |
84 |
Tomatin 15 Yr Moscatel |
POOR |
$140 |
86 |
Tomatin 10 Yr (1970’s – Imported to USA in 1998) |
POOR |
$170 |
87 |
Bomberger’s Declaration Kentucky Straight Bourbon, 2020 Release |
OK |
$90 |
86 |
Shenk’s Homestead Sour Mash Whiskey, 2020 Release |
OK |
$80 |
86 |
Starlight Carl T Huber’s Single Barrel Port-Finished Bourbon (Total Wine) |
GOOD |
$50 |
88 |
Old 55 Single Barrel Bourbon |
BEST |
$60 |
86 |
Ezra Brooks Distillers Collection Kentucky Straight Bourbon (Westport) |
GOOD |
$50 |
86 |
New Riff Maltster Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Made With Malted Wheat |
GOOD |
$55 |
87 |
Woodinville Single Barrel Straight Bourbon (Westport Store Pick) |
GOOD |
$75 |
86 |
New York Distilling 7 Year Rye (SMWS RW3.1 Big, bold, fruity & spicy) |
POOR |
$90 |
88 |
Alberta Premium Cask Strength Rye |
GOOD |
$70 |
88 |
NULU 7 Year Rye (Party Source) |
POOR |
$148 |
87 |
Wild Turkey Rare Breed Barrel Proof Rye, First Release |
BEST |
$65 |
86 |
Pinhook Tiz Rye Time 4 Year Straight Rye Whiskey (Westport Whiskey & Wine) |
GOOD |
$65 |
84 |
M.B. Roland Kentucky Straight Rye, Batch 3 |
OK |
$55 |
82 |
Castle & Key Restoration Rye Batch 1 |
OK |
$40 |
97 |
Springbank 26 Yr (SMWS 27.113 What A Song And Dance) |
POOR |
$795 |
92 |
Springbank 14 Yr Bourbon Wood |
OK |
$230 |
90 |
Glen Scotia 17 Yr (SMWS 93.140 Bacon On A Bonfire) |
GOOD |
$170 |
88 |
Glen Scotia 14 Yr – Malts Festival 2020 |
BEST |
$100 |
90 |
New Riff Single Barrel Bourbon, Barrel # 16-2786 BBQ Cocoa Puffs |
BEST |
$60 |
89 |
Westland American Single Malt Whiskey Cask No 2781 |
GOOD |
$125 |
87 |
Westland American Single Malt Whiskey Garryana 2020 5th Edition |
OK |
$150 |
86 |
Westland American Single Malt Whiskey Garryana 2019 Edition 4|1 |
POOR |
$165 |
89 |
Balmenach 2004 15 Yr (SMWS 48.110 Sooooternes!) |
GOOD |
$115 |
87 |
Glen Scotia 11 Yr Sherry Double Cask Finish |
BEST |
$73 |
86 |
Linkwood 14 Year Old 2006 (Infrequent Flyers Cask 6144) |
OK |
$110 |
92 |
Highland Park 2006 – 14 Yr – Connoisseurs Choice (Gordon & MacPhail) |
BEST |
$135 |
75 |
Breuckelen Single Malt 2013 (SMWS 142.1 Made in New York, New York) |
POOR |
$110 |
77 |
McKenzie Finger Lakes Rye (SMWS RW2.1 Out of the ordinary – in a very good way!) |
POOR |
$100 |
86 |
McKenzie Finger Lakes Bourbon (SMWS B6.1 Ginger-spiced sponge) |
POOR |
$90 |
87 |
Knob Creek 12 Yr Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
BEST |
$59 |
84 |
Elijah Craig Toasted Barrel Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
OK |
$50 |
85 |
Penelope Bourbon Four Grain Straight Bourbon Whiskey – Rosé Cask Finish |
GOOD |
$65 |
85 |
Kyrö Malt Rye |
POOR |
$100 |
84 |
Barrell Craft Spirits Rye – Cask Strength – Batch 1 |
POOR |
$85 |
92 |
Maker’s Mark Private Select – Bayway World of Liquor Store Pick #4 |
BEST |
$75 |
84 |
Waterford Dunmore Single Malt Irish Whisky |
POOR |
$110 |
86 |
The Lakes Single Malt Whisky – The Whiskymaker’s Edition: Colheita |
GOOD |
$85 |
89 |
Starward Australian Whisky – Single Cask Release – Astor |
BEST |
$85 |
87 |
Mars Maltage “Cosmo” Japanese Whisky |
BEST |
$85 |
88 |
Glenallachie 10 Yr Cask Strength Batch 3 |
BEST |
$80 |
90 |
Four Roses OESQ Cask Strength Single Barrel – Gordon’s Pick |
BEST |
$80 |
83 |
Drumshanbo Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey (Inaugural Release) |
OK |
$70 |
88 |
Glenrothes 12 Yr (SMWS 30.111 Inferno toffee pudding) |
GOOD |
$130 |
90 |
Longmorn 12 Yr (SMWS 7.237 Nutty by nature) |
BEST |
$130 |
87 |
Auchroisk 7 Yr (SMWS 95.37 Adventurous African safari) |
BEST |
$100 |
88 |
Ardmore 13 Yr (SMWS 66.161 Chateau du pork scratching) |
GOOD |
$115 |
89 |
Glen Grant 15 Yr (SMWS 9.174 Strawberry Jalapeno Ice Cream) |
GOOD |
$125 |
88 |
Tomatin Cask Strength Single Malt Scotch |
BEST |
$99 |
85 |
Penderyn Portwood Single Malt Welsh Whisky |
BEST |
$75 |
83 |
Nikka Days |
GOOD |
$50 |
86 |
Pinhook Straight Bourbon Whiskey (Gordon’s Store Pick) |
OK |
$70 |
90 |
Arran Sherry Cask The Bodega |
BEST |
$75 |
87 |
Method and Madness Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey |
BEST |
$85 |
87 |
Amrut Single Malt Whisky – Cask Strength |
BEST |
$73 |
87 |
Glenmorangie A Tale of Cake |
BEST |
$87 |
90 |
Elijah Craig 12 Yr Barrel Proof Bourbon (Batch C920) |
BEST |
$65 |
92 |
Octomore 10 Yr |
OK |
$208 |
90 |
Octomore 11.1 |
GOOD |
$162 |
87 |
Bruichladdich Islay Barley 2011 |
BEST |
$74 |
83 |
Bruichladdich Bere Barley 2010 |
GOOD |
$68 |
91 |
Loch Lomond 15 Yr (SMWS 112.51 Funky Irie Feeling) |
BEST |
$130 |
89 |
Glen Grant 15 Yr (SMWS 9.172 Quantum Endramglement) |
GOOD |
$125 |
82 |
Glenlivet Caribbean Reserve |
OK |
$35 |
83 |
Laphroaig 8 Yr (SMWS 29.270 Collateral drammage) – Feis Ile 2020 |
POOR |
$140 |
94 |
Lagavulin 20 Yr Feis Ile 2020 |
GOOD |
$240 |
88 |
Caol Ila 16 Yr Feis Ile 2020 |
OK |
$160 |
86 |
Bunnahabhain 10 Yr (Old Particular) |
BEST |
$52 |
90 |
Teeling Single Cask Chestnut Finish Cask # 29555 2005 |
BEST |
$125 |
91 |
Teeling Single Malt Brabazon Series 03 |
BEST |
$95 |
90 |
Kaiyo The Sheri, 2nd Edition |
BEST |
$100 |
84 |
Kaiyo Whisky The Single |
GOOD |
$45 |
86 |
Kaiyo Japanese Whisky (Mizunara Oak) |
BEST |
$50 |
90 |
Blair Athol 10 Yr (SMWS 68.34 Roasty-Toasty-Tasty) |
BEST |
$95 |
85 |
Ardmore 13 Yr (SMWS 66.162 A true harmony of flavours) |
OK |
$115 |
89 |
Glengoyne 20 Yr (Old Particular) |
GOOD |
$122 |
90 |
Highland Park 24 Yr (Gordon & MacPhail) |
POOR |
$234 |
88 |
Old Pulteney 21 Yr (Gordon & MacPhail) |
OK |
$160 |
85 |
The Beachcomber – Blended Batch 06 (SMWS) |
GOOD |
$90 |
87 |
Tyrconnell 10 Yr Single Malt Sherry Cask Finish Irish Whiskey |
BEST |
$60 |
86 |
Kilbeggan Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey |
BEST |
$42 |
88 |
Tyrconnell 10 Yr Single Malt Madeira Cask Finish |
BEST |
$52 |
90 |
Maker’s Mark Limited Edition 1995 – Gold Wax & Label Japanese Edition |
POOR |
$450 |
91 |
Wild Turkey 12 Yr 101 – 1990’s Japanese Release |
POOR |
$250 |
87 |
Wild Turkey 8 Yr 101 – USA Release 1965 |
POOR |
$500 |
86 |
Wild Turkey 8 Yr 101 – 1980’s Japanese Release |
POOR |
$150 |
88 |
Wild Turkey Tradition Bourbon – 1994 |
POOR |
$200 |
80 |
Old Fitzgerald Prime Bourbon |
OK |
$18 |
93 |
Benrinnes 22 Yr (SMWS 36.171 A smooth ride) |
GOOD |
$180 |
89 |
Glenfarclas 8 Yr (SMWS 1.217 Mezzalunas at dawn) |
GOOD |
$105 |
91 |
Craigellachie 16 Yr (SMWS 44.118 Gets your castanets clacking) |
GOOD |
$140 |
92 |
Craigellachie 8 Yr (SMWS 44.117 Happiness is a warm bung) |
BEST |
$95 |
80 |
Miltonduff 11 Yr (Cadenhead) |
POOR |
$83 |
87 |
Aberlour 12 Yr (SMWS 54.80 Banana Mexicana) |
GOOD |
$115 |
90 |
Aberlour A’bunadh Alba Batch #2 |
BEST |
$95 |
86 |
Penelope Bourbon Four Grain Straight Bourbon Whiskey – PX Finish |
N/A |
N/A |
89 |
Penelope Bourbon Four Grain Straight Bourbon Whiskey- Oloroso Finish |
N/A |
N/A |
88 |
Penelope Bourbon Barrel Strength Four Grain Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
BEST |
$57 |
85 |
Penelope Bourbon Four Grain Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
BEST |
$32 |
90 |
Taconic Distillery Double Barrel Maple Bourbon, Release #5 |
BEST |
$60 |
94 |
Bunnahabhain Feis Ile 2020 – 2002 Madeira Finish |
OK |
$245 |
91 |
Bunnahabhain Feis Ile 2020 – 2010 Moine Amontillado Finish |
BEST |
$122 |
76 |
Limestone Branch 100% Malted Rye (Toddy’s Liquors Store Pick) |
POOR |
$60 |
82 |
Wilderness Trail Settlers’ Select Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Rye – Barrel 15D17 |
POOR |
$64 |
88 |
Pinhook Single Barrel Straight Bourbon (Justin’s House of Bourbon) |
BEST |
$50 |
89 |
Four Roses Small Batch Select Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
BEST |
$55 |
86 |
Peerless 3 Year Single Barrel Rye “Orange Blossom” |
POOR |
$110 |
80 |
Ardnamurchan Warehouse Release Limited Batch (Batch #10) |
OK |
$65 |
87 |
Wolfburn From the Stills – Summer 2019 |
BEST |
$73 |
85 |
Talisker Distillery Exclusive 2019 |
OK |
$104 |
90 |
Longmorn 13 Yr Distillery Reserve Single Cask |
BEST |
$92 |
85 |
Shays’ Rebellion American Whiskey |
OK |
$120 |
91 |
Wild Turkey Master’s Keep “Revival” |
POOR |
$140 |
91 |
Redemption Rye 8 Yr (Batch 1) |
GOOD |
$90 |
76 |
Port Charlotte – Cask Exploration 17 |
POOR |
$150 |
92 |
Willowbank 1989 24 Yr (New Zealand Whisky Company) |
OK |
$220 |
73 |
Mackmyra First Edition |
POOR |
$90 |
79 |
Mortlach 15 Yr (Gordon & MacPhail) |
POOR |
$70 |
83 |
Macallan Edition No. 1 |
OK |
$90 |
84 |
Longmorn 12 Yr (SMWS 7.133 A bag of boiled sweets) |
POOR |
$120 |
89 |
Strathmill 12-Yr (SMWS 100.14 Boozy basil blueberry) |
GOOD |
$125 |
88 |
Loch Lomond 13 Yr Limousin Cask (SMWS 112.27 Tarry lapsang souchong) |
GOOD |
$135 |
87 |
Linkwood 26 Yr (SMWS 39.130 Zing like the ping of a musical string) |
POOR |
$235 |
86 |
Linkwood 14 Yr (SMWS 39.110 Builders at breaktime) |
OK |
$135 |
72 |
Jefferson’s Reserve Groth Cask Finish |
POOR |
$66 |
81 |
Tobermory 1994 21 Yr (Montgomerie’s Rare Cask Select) |
POOR |
$100 |
90 |
Highland Park 1999 15 Yr Cask Strength (Gordon & MacPhail) |
BEST |
$130 |
89 |
High West A Midwinter Night’s Dram Act 4, Scene 1 |
GOOD |
$70 |
90 |
Glenturret 2004 14 Yr Spirit of Speyside Festival 2018 (Gordon & MacPhail) |
GOOD |
$145 |
84 |
Glenmorangie Tüsail |
OK |
$100 |
71 |
Garrison Brothers Single Barrel Bourbon Exclusive Bottling for Astor Wines |
POOR |
$110 |
87 |
George A. Dickel Bourbon (SMWS B5.1 Sheer brilliance) |
POOR |
$225 |
85 |
The Exclusive Blend 1991 |
OK |
$115 |
89 |
Edradour 1989 Natural Cask Strength 14 Yr |
OK |
$160 |
83 |
Glenlivet Code |
POOR |
$115 |
87 |
Macallan Edition No. 3 |
BEST |
$90 |
89 |
Royal Brackla 17 Yr (SMWS 55.31 Sparkling, lively and playful) |
OK |
$150 |
93 |
Glenlossie 23 Yr (SMWS 46.45 A two-way street) |
GOOD |
$195 |
85 |
Dailuaine 12 Yr (SMWS 41.89 Tart Flambe) |
OK |
$130 |
89 |
Craigellachie 24 Yr (SMWS 44.65 Subtle complexity) |
POOR |
$210 |
90 |
Craigellachie 23 Yr |
POOR |
$280 |
85 |
Cragganmore 12 Yr (SMWS 37.83 An odyssey of flavour) |
OK |
$130 |
88 |
Compasss Box The Lost Blend |
GOOD |
$110 |
79 |
Chivas Regal 18 Yr Gold Signature |
POOR |
$80 |
86 |
Westward Astor Pick Single Cask Single Malt |
GOOD |
$100 |
88 |
Maker’s Mark Private Select RC6 |
GOOD |
$70 |
86 |
St George Baller Single Malt Whiskey |
BEST |
$75 |
87 |
High Wire New Southern Revival Rye |
BEST |
$60 |
87 |
Aberlour A’Bunadh Batch #62 |
BEST |
$95 |
86 |
Glengoyne Cask Strength Batch 005 |
GOOD |
$80 |
85 |
Black Button Double Barrel Four Grain Straight Bourbon |
N/A |
N/A |
86 |
Black Button Cask Strength Bourbon Batch 1 |
N/A |
N/A |
81 |
Black Button Bourbon Barrel # 575 |
N/A |
N/A |
85 |
Black Button Bourbon Barrel # 574 |
N/A |
N/A |
82 |
Black Button Bourbon Barrel # 566 |
N/A |
N/A |
87 |
Black Button Bourbon Barrel # 518 |
GOOD |
$68 |
87 |
Benromach Single Cask Gordon’s 2018 |
BEST |
$85 |
77 |
Benrinnes 13 Yr (SMWS 36.114 Tap-dancing tongue teaser) |
POOR |
$130 |
81 |
Ben Nevis 18 Yr (Montgomerie’s Choice) |
POOR |
$80 |
87 |
Caol Ila 10 Yr (SMWS 53.310 Kippers in slippers) |
GOOD |
$125 |
88 |
Tullibardine 11 Yr (SMWS 28.43 Muscle-toned heft and punch) |
GOOD |
$110 |
89 |
Glenfarclas 15 Yr (SMWS 1.215 Formidable chocolate) |
GOOD |
$135 |
85 |
Teaninich 10 Yr (SMWS 59.59 Spock’s earwax) |
GOOD |
$95 |
89 |
Glen Scotia 14 Yr (SMWS 93.120 Cocoa and coal) |
GOOD |
$135 |
90 |
Clynelish 9 Yr (SMWS 26.132 Krupnik and amaretti) |
BEST |
$110 |
80 |
Balmenach 2005 10 Yr (SMWS 48.74 Coffee kisses and lucky tatties) |
POOR |
$105 |
90 |
Aultmore 16 Yr (SMWS 73.79 Hopped-Up!) |
GOOD |
$150 |
87 |
Arran Smugglers’ Series Volume 2 – The High Seas |
OK |
$150 |
94 |
Arran Smugglers’ Series Volume 1 – The Illicit Stills |
BEST |
$130 |
90 |
Michter’s US 1 Single Barrel Fort Nelson Reserve Straight Rye |
POOR |
$150 |
91 |
Glenturret 9 Yr (SMWS 16.42 Top notes of covfefe) |
BEST |
$95 |
89 |
Glen Scotia 11 Yr (SMWS 93.119 Charcoal in a honeypot) |
GOOD |
$120 |
91 |
Glenlossie 17 Yr (SMWS 46.84 Velvet complexity) |
GOOD |
$140 |
82 |
Craigellachie 8 Yr (SMWS 44.116 Pirate ship in a storm) |
POOR |
$95 |
88 |
Miltonduff 11 Yr (SMWS 72.79 Chocolate bourbons) |
BEST |
$100 |
86 |
Macduff 12 Yr (SMWS 6.32 Knickerbockers at a wedding) |
OK |
$105 |
81 |
Royal Brackla 10 Yr (SMWS 55.57 Digging up ginger) |
POOR |
$100 |
87 |
Glenburgie 7 Yr (SMWS 71.66 Farmyard feedback loop) |
BEST |
$90 |
89 |
Bunnahabhain 4 Yr Staoisha Heavily Peated (Signatory Vintage for The Whisky Hoop) |
BEST |
$85 |
88 |
Tobermory 11 Yr (Signatory Vintage for The Whisky Hoop) |
GOOD |
$130 |
88 |
Glendronach 22 Yr (Oloroso Sherry Puncheon for The Whisky Hoop) |
POOR |
$190 |
87 |
Clynelish 23 Yr (Signatory Vintage for The Whisky Hoop) |
POOR |
$190 |
93 |
Arran 16 Yr (Private Cask for The Whisky Hoop) |
BEST |
$140 |
86 |
Talisker 6 Yr (The Old Malt Cask for The Whisky Hoop) |
GOOD |
$85 |
88 |
The Octave – The Whisky Peddler – An Iconic Speyside (Glenfarclas) – Distilled 2008 |
BEST |
$85 |
89 |
Craigellachie 19 Yr Exceptional Cask # 129 |
POOR |
$199 |
87 |
Craigellachie 17 Yr |
OK |
$160 |
89 |
Aberfeldy 24 Yr Exceptional Cask, Cask # 6933 |
POOR |
$279 |
92 |
Aberfeldy 20 Yr Exceptional Cask, Cask # 119 |
POOR |
$320 |
88 |
Aberfeldy 21 Yr |
OK |
$150 |
82 |
Journeyman Corsets, Whips & Whiskey, Barrel BWW-17-2197 |
OK |
$48 |
83 |
Journeyman Corsets, Whips & Whiskey, Barrel BWW-17-2192 |
GOOD |
$48 |
84 |
Journeyman Corsets, Whips & Whiskey, Barrel BWW-17-2191 |
GOOD |
$48 |
85 |
Journeyman Corsets, Whips & Whiskey, Barrel CWW-17-1868 |
BEST |
$48 |
83 |
Journeyman Corsets, Whips & Whiskey, Barrel CWW-17-1867 |
GOOD |
$48 |
79 |
Journeyman Featherbone Bourbon |
POOR |
$38 |
80 |
Journeyman Last Feather Rye Single Barrel Store Pick (Georgetown Wine & Spirits) |
OK |
$40 |
91 |
Writers Tears Single Cask Japanese Mizunara Cask Finish |
BEST |
$95 |
86 |
Clonakilty Single Grain 9 Yr Bordeaux Cask Finish, Batch 001 Handfill |
GOOD |
$85 |
88 |
Teeling Single Cask # 22060 Sherry Cask Handfill 10 Yr |
GOOD |
$120 |
78 |
Tullamore DEW Caribbean Rum Cask Finish |
POOR |
$38 |
89 |
WhistlePig Old World 12 Yr Cask Finish Rye – Saratoga Whiskey Club Bespoke Blend |
POOR |
$110 |
84 |
Caol Ila 6 Yr (SMWS 53.276 Ein kleiner deutsche samurai) |
OK |
$100 |
88 |
Aultmore 17 Yr (SMWS 73.114 Total eclipse of oloroso) |
OK |
$145 |
91 |
Glenturret 18 Yr (SMWS 16.39 Sweetness and spice laced with mystery) |
GOOD |
$145 |
92 |
Bunnahabhain 11 Yr (SMWS 10.176 Tea-smoked salmon) |
BEST |
$125 |
88 |
Glen Grant 23 Yr (SMWS 9.167 Part of the furniture) |
POOR |
$220 |
85 |
Craigellachie 12 Yr (SMWS 44.114 Sweet peas and toffee trees) |
OK |
$105 |
82 |
Mannochmore 8 Yr (SMWS 64.111 Pleasing sweetness, playful heat) |
POOR |
$85 |
87 |
Glenfarclas 8 Yr (SMWS 1.211 Ironing a lemon) |
BEST |
$90 |
88 |
Lagavulin 11 Yr Offerman Edition |
BEST |
$75 |
90 |
Dingle Founding Fathers The Palace Bar |
POOR |
$283 |
84 |
The Irishman Cask Strength Irish Whiskey 2019 Edition |
POOR |
$118 |
90 |
Cooley 11 Yr Irish Whiskey (27 yr) Cadenhead’s Open Day Big Tasting 2019 |
BEST |
$122 |
94 |
Celtic Cask 27 Fiche Seacht Single Cask Single Malt |
BEST |
$189 |
89 |
Teeling Brabazon Single Malt Series 2 |
BEST |
$85 |
92 |
Michter’s US 1 Toasted Barrel Finish Rye |
BEST |
$75 |
84 |
Yellowstone Limited #3-Char Wine Cask Finish Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$100 |
88 |
Bardstown Phifer Pavitt Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon Finish Straight Bourbon |
POOR |
$125 |
93 |
Highland Park Twisted Tattoo |
BEST |
$100 |
87 |
Sagamore Spirit Port Finish Rye Whiskey |
BEST |
$65 |
86 |
Writers Tears Florio Marsala Cask Finish Irish Whiskey |
GOOD |
$85 |
88 |
Glenlivet Enigma |
GOOD |
$130 |
87 |
Macallan Edition No. 4 |
BEST |
$100 |
90 |
Kavalan Gordon’s Store Pick Ex-Bourbon Single Cask No. B1011214024A |
OK |
$180 |
83 |
Balblair 2005 Single Cask Gordon’s Store Pick |
OK |
$95 |
90 |
1792 Full Proof Bourbon Gordon’s Barrel Selection 2019 |
BEST |
$45 |
88 |
Caol Ila 12 Yr (SMWS 53.287 Ye old medisin) |
GOOD |
$130 |
89 |
Old Pulteney 11 Yr (SMWS 52.25 A morning at the beach) |
GOOD |
$120 |
91 |
Glen Moray 23 Yr (SMWS 35.224 Fata Morgana) |
POOR |
$230 |
90 |
Auchentoshan 18 Yr (SMWS 5.70 In the absence of convention) |
GOOD |
$155 |
85 |
Glenfarclas 7 Yr (SMWS 1.209 Waxing a hot woodsman) |
GOOD |
$95 |
88 |
Glen Scotia 7 Yr (SMWS 93.107 Flexing the mussels) |
GOOD |
$105 |
88 |
Port Charlotte Islay Barley |
BEST |
$70 |
89 |
Willett Family Estate Small Batch Rye 4 Yr |
BEST |
$60 |
84 |
Catskill Straight Rye Whiskey |
GOOD |
$43 |
86 |
Black Maple Hill Oregon Straight Bourbon Whiskey |
POOR |
$90 |
86 |
New Riff Kentucky Straight Bourbon |
BEST |
$40 |
89 |
Colonel E.H. Taylor Straight Rye |
GOOD |
$80 |
90 |
Bunnahabhain 10 Yr Peated Port Finish (SMWS 10.118 Enthralling Pink and Peat Intensity) |
BEST |
$130 |
87 |
Catoctin Creek Roundstone Rye Single Barrel Maple Finish 18E13 |
OK |
$99 |
86 |
Catoctin Creek Roundstone Rye Single Barrel Cask Proof 18E17 |
POOR |
$99 |
84 |
Catoctin Creek Roundstone Rye Distillers Edition Single Barrel 19G01 |
OK |
$46 |
82 |
Catoctin Creek Roundstone Rye Single Barrel Batch 18H33 |
OK |
$40 |
90 |
Ichiro’s Malt, Cask # 1487 |
POOR |
$250 |
92 |
Glen Grant 30 Yr (SMWS 9.150 Thyme well spent) |
POOR |
$325 |
90 |
Glen Grant 25 Yr (SMWS 9.152 Mindful savouring) |
POOR |
$275 |
92 |
Glen Grant 22 Yr (SMWS 9.155 Witches’ night) |
OK |
$225 |
87 |
Glen Grant 21 Yr (SMWS 9.148 Mustard, custard and musk) |
POOR |
$190 |
91 |
Glen Grant 21 Yr (SMWS 9.147 Cocktails in a coal mine) |
OK |
$190 |
84 |
Bruichladdich The Classic Laddie Scottish Barley |
GOOD |
$57 |
86 |
Westland Sherry Wood American Single Malt |
GOOD |
$80 |
84 |
Westland Peated American Single Malt |
OK |
$80 |
83 |
Westland American Oak American Single Malt |
GOOD |
$70 |
88 |
Westland American Single Malt Single Cask for Astor Wines (Cask 118) |
BEST |
$100 |
90 |
Westland American Single Malt Cask # 2479 (K&L) – Sherry |
BEST |
$110 |
87 |
Johnnie Walker Black Label The Director’s Cut Blade Runner 2049 |
GOOD |
$95 |
90 |
Michter’s Limited Edition Barrel Strength Rye |
BEST |
$80 |
87 |
Aberlour 9 Yr (SMWS 54.42 A washing day in Spring) |
BEST |
$100 |
83 |
Deveron 12 Yr |
GOOD |
$40 |
78 |
Royal Brackla 12 Yr |
POOR |
$65 |
82 |
Craigellachie 13 Yr |
OK |
$55 |
81 |
Aberfeldy 12 Yr |
OK |
$43 |
95 |
Bunnahabhain 27 Yr (Distiller’s Art) |
POOR |
$400 |
81 |
Paul John Classic Select Cask Single Malt |
POOR |
$80 |
91 |
Kavalan Symphony Single Cask No. B1011240764 |
OK |
$180 |
77 |
The Exclusive Regions Single Grain 12 Yr |
POOR |
$50 |
85 |
Hibiki Japanese Harmony – Master’s Select |
GOOD |
$89 |
82 |
Kaiyo Cask Strength Malt Whisky (Mizunara Oak) |
POOR |
$90 |
88 |
Ichiro’s Malt MWR – Mizunara Wood Reserve |
BEST |
$70 |